42 answers

Asthma and Pets

My 2 year old was just diagnosed with Asthma. We ended up in the emergency room with an acute attack. We don't know yet what his triggers are, he has had about 4 attacks this year already, but we now know it is asthma.
We have 2 cats. The doctor couldn't tell us for sure that cats are his trigger, and suggested re-homing them. The cats are very much a part of the family, our 2 year old (along with our other children) love them. Do we have to get rid of our cats, or is there someway to keep them and keep our son safe from potential triggers. The doctor said there is no medical test to determine his triggers. The doctor said cats may or may not be a trigger for him, so I am hesitant to upset the entire family if the cats are not a trigger. This is my youngest, and the only one with asthma or allergies. (He was allergy tested and tested negative to cats - but the ER doctor said that does not indicate airway triggers, only skin allergies) Any advice?

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

Hi, I have had asthma since I was 3 months old. Doctors told my parents to get rid of all pets. my parents refused to do that since people told them, it was better to keep them so that my immune system could get used to it. I am glad they did. I did get used to them and now I love all animals and dont have any asthma attacks due to them anymore.

I can remember when I was diagnosed with asthma. The first thing that they told me was what the triggers were that induced my attacks. I have had cats in my house as well as dogs and have had no problems with my asthma. One of the biggest things that I have found that triggers my asthma is dust and aerosoles (sp) sprays like cleaners, air freshners, spray deodrants, perfumes and colognes. I would recommend going to a pulmonologist.

While I understand the love of pets, and the great things that they bring to the home, at the end of the day they are just that, pets. They are animals, in my opinion they come a far second in my family. If I even thought a pet that I might have could have a serious affect on one of my children, I would have no second thoughts rehoming them. You aren't putting the animals down, they can still have a loving caring family, just a different family.

Good luck! For me this decision is black and white but I can see how this could be difficult for you.

More Answers

Morning R.;

Your cats probably are not the triggers! I had asthma as
a kid, medical doctors do not understand asthma!
My mother was told to move to Arizona by a medical doctor.

Asthma is an "Allergy"! But, also there are nerves that cause
the closing of that little tube that blocks the airwave. A
good chiropractor can strengthen those nerves to make the
attacks less frequent and also show you where to rub when
he has an attack.
Just a personal note, my mother took me to a chiropractor
when I was in the 7th grade. Medical doctors said that I
should never play any type of sports. After just a few months
of treatment I started playing football in the 7th grade,
I played football, ran track, played basketball from then on
all the way thru the Army where I won regional meets in
track and played football on the Artillery team. I set a
track record in the High Hurdles in high school and went to
the state meet.
Talk to a chiropractor, but make sure it is one that learned
the Palmer Method!
B. C.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi R.,
Im a mother of three,none of my children have asthma but i do.In our home we have a chihuahua we adore.I love cats too.I've heard the same thing that cats will trigger asthma attacks.A couple of months ago someone in our neighborhood was giving kittens away and we decided to bring one home.I tested the thoery on cats triggering asthma.The cat was only in our home for 4 days.I started to feel my chest get tight shortness of breath all the symtoms that feel that come along before an asthma attack.Soooo i took the kitten back were i picked it up at.cleaned the house as best as i could to eliminate cat hair that was left behind and used Lysol spray were the cat layed the most and through out the house,soon after i was back to normal in my breathing.
Maybe if you decide to get your cats another home you can get a small dogs.Dogs don't have the same affect,why who knows?Chihuahuas are know to be good with people who have asthma.My dog is so attached to me.My children say "i think he thinks your his mama".lol.If you do decide to get a chihuahua make sure when you get him to introduce him to your son first.Its known that whoever the dog meets first and gives him the attention the dog will become attach to more.Also chihuahuas are known to beable to sense when things are not right in humans such as when i would get symtoms of an attack {asthma}he would feel it and become real protective and would'nt leave my side.Old wives tale i've heard to is that chihuahuas prevent asthma attacks.I know i havn't had one since i've had my dog these last 3 years.So possibly could be true.I still do my inhaler as before once a day as directed.
I thinks getting rid of the cats will be harder for you than your son.Children that age can easly be comforted w/a substitue.So if you do decide to get your cats a new home maybe consider getting a small dog possibly a chihuahua.They are also VERY smart and easy to train.Good Luck and if possible let me know your outcome.Thanks
T.

Do you have some where the cats can stay for a little while?? Long enough to see what happens. We have two cats and a dog. Our son has asthma and it helped him when we took up the carpet and put in laminate flooring. However,in the end the health of our child comes before pets.. Good luck!!!

I got the "Air Source 3000" Air purifier for our home. We have a daughter who had terrible attacks when young. Tried every air purifier...this only one that really got results.

www.yourhealthyalternatives.com has an "Air Purification" page ...

Also, is your home older? Many older homes carry hidden molds which could be the cause. AS willhelp with this, also.

It is not the cats that could be triggering this but the cat dander. I would hate to see you get rid of the cats and upset the family if it isn't the cat dander causing the problems. Make sure you cats stay clean and brushed will help, but I can't help but think it is not the cats or you would be having more symptoms daily and more often. I would also hate to see you get rid of the cats and it turns out not to be the cats and you have to then explain why you got rid of them and upset your children. You didn't say where you live and I know here in San Antonio the allergens have been horrible with all the humidity, mold etc. in the air. My grandchild has the same problems and she is and has slowly grown out of it and they have a cat. Hers seems more seasonal to me. I have allergies as well and my husband has asthma and we have pets. We left them outside for a while and it turned out not to be the pets at all and again it comes with the air quality etc.
Good luck to you and just keep the cats clean and brushed as brushing will help rid of the dander. I would bush them in a utility room, garage or outdoors vs. inside the main part of the house and see if that helps. You just have to really pay attention when these attacks happen and you will slowly figure out what the cause possibly is. Again Good Luck.

Did the doctor prescribe an antihistimine? Zyrtec can be given to children as young as 2 years, and if you give it to him for a week or two and see a big improvement in his symptoms, then you can safely assume that his asthma is triggered by allergies and the cats may be the culprit. If, however, he takes antihistimines for awhile and nothing changes, then chances are the allergies are not to blame. My 11-year-old daughter has had severe asthma all her life. We had a cat when she was born; the cat passed away when she was about 5, and her asthma actually got WORSE after that. We then got another cat when she was 9 and she has steadily improved since that time. She was also allergy tested, tested negative to everything (including pet dander), and her allergest said this proved she doesn't have allergies and the pets are not triggers for her asthma. Her attacks are always triggered by infection (viruses, bacterial infections) or by environmental irritants (high pollution or a big weather change). I would check with the doc about trying the antihistimine--it could give you enough information to bring you peace of mind in knowing you are making the right decision regarding your pets.

R.,
The first thing you might want to do, is rip up the carpet and put in tile or hardwood flooring. Carpet holds an enormous amount of dander, dirt, and dust, and could be triggering his attacks. Once the carpet is gone, see if he has any more of these attacks. Also,if you have any down or feather pillows, replace them with the hypoallergenic type. Good luck!

I would put my child's welfare ahead of my cats, that is your role as a parent.

That being said, maybe you have a friend or relative who could take the cats for six months or so and see if he has problems while they are gone, and then see what happens when they return.

My sons have asthma but have never had the acute more life threatening attacks. He is old enough to be on a preventative med (like Flovent or one of the others out there) so if he is not, he needs to be.

When my son started having asthma as an infant, we did put our cat outside, but kept our dog (he was a non shedding breed) but kept him isolated in a room for the most part. It was a sad,but easy decision for me as a mom, as asthma can be life threatening, and I was not going to risk my sons' life. The problem w/ cats, is their dander and molecules that come from their saliva when they lick themselves, which of course they do almost constantly.

Once your son is older, and on meds for a while, hopefully his asthma will improve, and not be so scary (as their airways get larger as they get older, they sometimes get much milder symptoms, but as a baby/toddler the problems are usually worse).

Please talk further to the doctor, but be careful with your little one's health. I highly recommend letting the cats go to a friends (or at least put them in another part of the house to reduce your son's exposure to them) until you decide what to do.

Good luck and I hope I was not too hard on you or scary. I made it through two sons with mild to moderate asthma and it does seem to improve as they age. I am an animal lover but nothing compares to the mother's instinct to protect her child!! Listen to that instinct.

Take care.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.