32 answers

Anyone an Only Child or Have an Only Child (By Life Happenstance or by Choice?)

I am a single woman on an adoption waiting list for a baby girl. I'm 47 and after much heartbreak of not meeting Mr. Right five years ago I decided to become a parent on my own. I tried to have biological kids a few years ago, but it was too late. I tried donor egg, that didn't work. Now I'm adopting and after a long wait I am very close to having my child. I've always envisioned if I was married I'd have three kids. But as a single woman, I planned to adopt two. Now I've met someone who has two grown kids and wasn't planning on having anymore. We love each other very much and he knows that this is a dealbreaker for me. I was on the adoption list when he met me and I was up front with him that I wanted two. We are talking about getting married and he's decided he's willing to raise one child with me. I am trying to think this through and look at all sides.

This feels like another loss to me - having gone through grieving not meeting Mr. Right in time to have a couple of biological children together, grieving that I couldn't have biological children on my own, then grieving multiple miscarriages with donor eggs, now, the 28 month wait to adopt a baby - giving up having two children feels like another loss to me.

I grew up with three siblings and always wanted my children to have siblings. I never wanted an only child. I'm worried my child will be lonely. My sister is my best friend, although I have two brothers I'm not close with, so I know that siblings don't always get along as adults. I want her to have that best friend that she shared her childhood growing up experience with. Also, when I'm gone, I want her to have someone to be there for her if she doesn't get married. I want her to have someone to help with responsibilities if she has to take care of me in my old age. I want the sounds of family chaos in my house. I don't think that there is any replacement for siblings - even a best friend is just not the same. My mom always said she wishes she had a sister.

I'm worried I'll regret not having two - that it will come between me and him. That I'll always be resentful - he has a sibling, his kids have siblings, I have siblings, why should my child not have siblings? I'm also worried that an only child will be much more needy and dependent on us as parents for entertainment because she won't have a built in sibling playmate - that this will create even more work for my husband to be, when he didn't originally want to parent in the first place (don't get me wrong - I know that by committing to having one, he's going to be a faithful and good dad - I'm just worried).

Anyone out there can share their experience either as an only child or as someone who originally planned to have two or more, but ended up with one - either by happenstance or by life choice? What are the pros and cons? How did you feel if you originally wanted more than one - but ended up with one? Do you regret it?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks for such wonderful responses! I appreciate your honesty and sharing. The bf and I need to do some more talking and I need to do some more thinking, but this has been SO helpful!

Featured Answers

I asked an only child q a couple years ago and got an AMAZING list of responses. Over 40. A few are "you'll nuts, you'll regret it", but the rest are parents of onlys and only children themselves... so here's another 40 some odd answers about great things about having an only child:

http://www.mamapedia.com/questions/5929452319845515265

2 moms found this helpful

I was not an only, but I don't have a close relationship with my sister and never have. I'm there for her if she needs me, but even if we lived near each other, we wouldn't hang out cause we have nothing in common. I used to wish I was an only child, actually, or a twin LOL.

My son is an only and I expect he will stay that way because I'm almost 44 and don't want to push it too much longer. We're not using birth control and nothing's happened since he was born 5 years ago.

It would be nice if he could have a sibling, but he'll be fine. Blood doesn't guarantee relationship, really. I was lonely with a sibling cause we didn't get along.

1 mom found this helpful

Yes, I do now regret it.

Until she was about 7, I never questioned it.
Then it would have been nice for a playmate. Also, with medical issues, I think about when I am gone. Though both my husband and I had psycho siblings, I would like for her to have someone. We both had mothers who helped reinforce and enable all bad behavior. We didn't want the drama.

More Answers

Only children are not "lonely." Do you really think only children grow up without any friends. My closest family, are actually people who are friends. I have sisters, and I'm not close with them at all. There is a year age difference between each of us, so it's not the age gap. We have simply never been close. They live less then 30 minutes away from me, and I can go a year or more without seeing/talking to them. When my parents pass, I can tell you I won't be crying on their shoulder. I will be crying on the shoulder of my friend of over a decade. One who is much more a sister then my others could ever be. You are adopting, so you KNOW DNA is not a requirement for family. Love is found in PEOPLE, not blood. I can tell you a best friend IS the same for me. In every way, actually better. It IS for a lot of people.

I have an only, by choice. I don't think for a second he will be lonely in his life. He loves, and people love him. MOST of the people that love him dearly, are of no blood relation at all. Those relationships will be there forever. I know many only children, and it was the opposite. They were MORE independent and creative thinking. They relied on others LESS for entertainment.

If you're worried about a child creating "work" for your fiance, then you need to rethink this arrangement. Children are WORK. HARD WORK. They create more work, then you could ever imagine. If he has a problem with working, sacrificing, losing himself in parenting at times, not being a priority at times, being exhausted by the needs of a child, giving everything to that child in some moments, working in a thankless manner...what kind of father will he really be? I'm sorry to be so harsh, but you can't shield him from "extra work." He has to be WILLING to take on LOTS of extra work, because of his love and desire to mold a healthy child.

8 moms found this helpful

I have an only (by choice) and he's certainly not lacking or lonely!

I think the bigger issue for you to ponder is your relationship.

If your BF is dead set against more kids and is "willing" to raise one child with you (how generous) I would be leery of the entire relationship. Not that he's not entitled to his preferences, but the fact that he's so willing to shut down YOUR desires.

But who knows, maybe when you get the one, you'll feel that one is more than enough? You never know.

Good luck!

6 moms found this helpful

We have an only child by choice and have absolutely NO regrets. Our family was complete with one. I never had a desire for more children, neither did hubby... we were always on the same page.

Of course you have normal worries but your worries are compounded by all the hype that is told over and over about only chilldren and only child syndrome and liken only children to some sort of disease. I do not believe in the only child syndrome.

Are there some very needy, spoiled brat only children? Of course... but there are plenty of those who have siblings as well. It is called parenting and how you parent your children as to how they behave and how needy they are.

We have raised our daughter to be very independent and responsible. She thrives on this and always has. She is 17 now and when she was born the Dr. said... "you have a strong willed baby". Never in a million years would I have squashed that trait because it is a very positive trait... sometimes difficult to navigate through, of course but we are SO very pround of the young woman our daughter has become. She has set her golas high for college and career and lives her life as her dad and I do.... Failure is NOT an option and Never Give Up.

She has never asked for siblings. We have been able to provide very well for her... college fully funded, we are funded so we will never be a burden to her, travel, she is set up financially and we have a very stable, secure family bond.

She is very involved with us, we have good relationships with her and our communication is wide open. She works with us with our family owned business so that she has hands on experience with business basics because she intends for one of her majors to be in business.

We've never had a shortage of friends in our house. My house has always been full of friends, playdates, etc. She has the entire upstairs to herself and loves to have her friends over. Many kids come here and have told me they come here to get away from bickering, siblings, etc and just have peace and my cooking for a while.

No one can tell you what is right or wrong for you. You have to go with what is best for you and your family. As for us, we would not change a thing. We've enjoyed every moment with our only child and we are in preparation to proudly send her off to the college of her dreams so she can fulfill her goals.

Best wishes to you...

6 moms found this helpful

I wanted a houseful of children when I got married at 25. I finally got 1 boy @ 37 yrs old and I am grateful every day I get to spend with him. I do not mourn or grieve what I don't have (more children). That is time and emotions taken away from what I do have (my husband, son, friends, family, a good life).

Pros? It sure is cheaper to have just one child. Cons? I really can't think of one. Companionship was never a problem. We liked playing with our son and having him never stopped us from doing anything we wanted to do. Once he started preschool @ 3, we always got together with other friends so socialization was always encouraged.

If you plan on being a mother, stop comparing yourself to the life of others and how things should be. You are going to burn out before your child is a year old. Life with a child is unpredictable at best. Good parents have bad kids, bad parents have good kids, smoking parents have non smoking kids, religious parents have athiest kids.

5 moms found this helpful

No one gets any guarantees about anythiing.

You weren't guaranteed the right relationship, at the right time, to have the right child at the right age. So you are being proactive and adopting a child who needs you --which is great and very giving of you. But please don't mourn what you don't have and never were guaranteed, which is a second child.

Bear in mind: Adoptions do have problems, and you don't have the first child yet; I hate to say it but the fact you're high up on the adoption list doesn't guarantee you'll have a child tomorrow, or even soon; parents can change their minds about giving up kids for adoption at all. Will you then grieve that first child on top of grieving over a second child who isn't even on anyone's horizon? Focus on one child at a time.

You haven't tried parenthood with just one yet. Though right now you are convinced two is your magic number, you may find that one is right for you. Children are demanding, at all ages. You are the same age as me (my daughter is nearly 11); do think about this: If you adopt a baby right now, you will be 57 when your child is 10 years old; 65--retirement age--when your child is 18 and just starting college; and so on. Let's be very clear here: I am NOT saying you're too old to adopt; no one is too old to give their love and lifelong devotion to a child. But I am saying that especially with another adult in the picture, you should consider some tough things that no one likes to think about, like finances and your own later years. What were your plans for your own retirement; your finances for your child's education and other expenses; your energy level and ability to spend time with your child in those first 18 years, and so on? One child may be perfect for that, but two could tip you into the territory of having to work much longer than intended, or do without retiring, etc. It sounds selfish to discuss it, right? But doesn't talking about it now beat getting a few years down the road to find your new husband, and maybe yourself, thinking, two was one too many?

I would discuss all this with the gentleman in question, frankly and openly. If you feel you cannot discuss with him these seemingly "unfeeling" but very important things, like finances and your ages relative to a new child, you should think again about whether he's perfect for you; these are the brutal but realistic questions that parents have to face, and if you can't discuss them with him -- is he OK with being a 65-year-old dad of a new college kid? Does he buy in 100 percent that this is his child, 100 percent, as much as yours? and so on -- well, if you can't talk about that, it's no basis for a relationship.

By the way, only kids are not necessarily spoiled. They are not necessarily lonely. They are what their parents make of them, and if the parents spoil them or keep them on a short leash they'll have the problems you'd expect. I love having one child. It has enabled me to be MUCH more involved in her school by volunteering, something I see parents with two or more kids often can't do because they have a younger one to deal with so can't be at the older one's school. Having one child means having the time to help with scouting or other activities as you are needed. I know that parents of more than one do manage it but it is quite frankly easier with one. And kids do not "need" siblings for companionship or playmates or lifelong friends; I know plenty of adults whose siblings have nothing in common with them and who even dislike their siblings. Again-- there is no guarantee that providing a sibling for your child will provide a lifetime of warm memories and closeness with that sibling.

4 moms found this helpful

I think that your heart is torn because you love him, but you really do want 2 kids. If it's truly the dealbreaker you say it is, then don't marry someone who won't allow you have your dream. You've waited 47 years to be a mom and before you met him, you were willing to go it alone. Don't compromise on it, IMO.

My DD is not an "only" in the sense that she has half-sibs, but she is that she is MY only and they are so much older. Even though we build her family ties as often as we can (5 cousins within a couple of years of her) it's not the same and sometimes I mourn that. You can raise a happy only child. But will you be a happy mother if you didn't try for #2?

4 moms found this helpful

I agree weigh your options and talk it over with your boyfriend. My daughter is an only child and she is 5, yes she'd love a sibling, but her idea of a sibling is a playmate, when even if I decide to have another child they will not be able to play together because they will be so far apart. By the time you can adopt another their age gap may be so large that the playmate reasoning is null. I think you have to decide if YOU want another child for YOU and not for your child. If you do want another child and want to adopt an older child so they will have a playmate and sibling I guess you could go that route. Honestly thats tough. The love of a child is priceless, but so is being in love and having a life long partner. If you concieved naturally with him and then found out you couldn't again and he didn't want to adopt would you leave him then? I'd think your answer should be the same.

4 moms found this helpful

I would be more concerned about the relationship . . . it sounds like this man is reluctant about more kids, having been there and done that. And that's OK. I applaud his honesty with you. It just doesn't sound like the ideal situation though.

I agree with another mom that you have no idea - yet - how it will be with one child, much less two. It's great to have a vision, but sometimes God's plan is different than our own notion of what is best.

I would give all of this much thought and prayer. True happiness comes from within . . . for us moms, adults with no kids, only kids, and kids with numerous siblings. JMO.

There is also more than one way to care for and "parent" children, without necessarily being a parent. I would give that some thought too.

<<hugs>>

4 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.