25 answers

Any Good Toddler Discipline Books?

Hey ladies. Well, I come to you again for wonderful guidance. I have a 23 month old little boy who thinks he is already in charge and figured out the world. He is generally happy, affectionate, and playful, quick to pick up new things, but also VERY stubborn, little patience and easily figures out a way around most of our tactics for discipline and distraction. I am a true believer that love & firm guidance is the best discipline, but also know that I may be heading into uncharted waters (YAY terrible two's!) where I may need more than one method for success. Do any of you mom's out there have books you found very helpful and effective in raising a spirited child, helping them to grow and encourage their sense of independence, all while continuing to build a trusting and loving relationship while decreasing the number of meltdown battles.

3 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Once again, the mama squad has come through with some fantastic advice, support, and suggestions. I got a wonderful pool of responses with real solutions, and my husband and I will be doing some book shopping this weekend. Always nice to know you're not alone. Thank you moms!

Featured Answers

I have to second "Positive Discipline the First Three Years" by Jane Nelsen. It is an amazing book, full of great advice and something you can refer back to over and over again. I highly recommend her books to anyone looking for a good discipline book.

Using her techniques has helped me raise a spirited, independent, calm and loving 5 yr old boy.

1 mom found this helpful

The "help me be good" books offered through Scholastic. They also come with a sticker chart to mark progress.

rent Best Toddler on the Block dvd..very helpful..i also like What to Expect the Toddler Years..my toddler is 32 months..and now it's so easy b/c he's talking and i can talk to him and explain "why" and make little deals with him..
Like when we go to the gym..he used to say.."i don't like it" and get upset..so i explained that i really don't like going to the park every day but i go for him..so could he please just go to the gym for a little while so i can have some fun" never complained again about it.

More Answers

My recommendation is "Boundaries with Kids" by Dr. Cloud and Townsend. Here is an editorial review:

"Review
What the Award-Winning Boundaries Has Done for Adult Relationships Boundaries with Kids Will Do for You and Your Children Here at last is the help you need for raising your kids to take responsibility for their actions, attitudes, and emotions. Drs. Henry Cloud and John Townsend take you through the ins and outs of establishing family boundaries and of instilling the kind of character in your children that will help them lead balanced, productive, and fulfilling adult lives. Learn how to
? set limits and still be a loving parent

? bring control to an out-of-control family life

? apply the ten laws of boundaries to parenting

? define legitimate boundaries for your family . . . and much more -- Publisher --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.

Product Description
Since the 1992 release of their Gold Medallion Award-winning book, Boundaries, Drs. Henry Cloud and John Townsend have heard these three questions rephrased thousands of times. As parents begin to realize the tremendous impact poor boundaries have had on their own lives, their concern naturally extends to their children. How can they help their sons and daughters form healthy boundaries that lead to well-rounded characters and successful adult lives? Now there are answers. Boundaries with Kids helps parents apply the Ten Laws of Boundaries (first described in Boundaries) to the challenges of raising children. In their popular, readable style, Cloud and Townsend help moms and dads make choices and develop a parenting approach that sees beyond the moment to the adults their children will become. For parents who want their kids to escape the struggles they themselves have experienced, here’s an in-depth look at how to implement the preventive medicine of character development by establishing sound boundaries starting with the parents. Boundaries with Kids helps moms and dads learn how to
bring control to an out-of-control family life
set limits and still be loving parents define what legitimate boundaries are in the family transfer what they are learning as parents to help their children develop healthy boundaries. Illustrating its points with numerous case studies and anecdotes, Boundaries with Kids gives parents the can-do guidance they need in order to model healthy boundaries for their kids. This book may well be the best investment parents will ever make into the lifelong welfare of their children."

4 moms found this helpful

I love The Discipline Book by Dr. Sears. My kids are 3.5 (boy) and 6yo (girl). I've never had to resort to spanking/hitting or yelling to get them to behave. It's hard work but they behave because they know it is the right thing to do rather than behave because they are afraid of what might happen if they don't. They have consequences, we have rules, they are disciplined. I say that because some people think gentle discipline means no discipline - not at all. I've found that it's more about teaching. We have to teach our kids out to behave, what's OK, what's not. They aren't born with this information.

Best wishes,
M.

2 moms found this helpful

Hi K.,
I'm currently reading "Positive Discipline the First Three Years" by Jane Nelsen. I'm not through it yet, but am really encouraged by her distinction between punishment and discipline and how we can teach boundaries without instilling shame and self-doubt in our children. Sounds like our sons have a bit in common - mine is NOT easily distracted either. Best of luck to us both!

2 moms found this helpful

Hi K.,

You are a great mom and it sounds like you've got a great game plan already by wanting to really nurture his independence and so on! Raising little boys is so fun and challenging! I have 2 boys, a girl and another boy one on the way! My boys were 2 years apart and very spirited!! I loved the books "Raising Your Spirited Child" (its a little out dated now but it still has lots of great tips) And I love "Parenting with Love and Logic" By Foster Cline. Its very practical parenting strategies and encourages giving your child choices that are appropriate and letting them expierience the natural consequences. It helps you stay on their side and helps them through the choice they have picked. EX: not too long ago my son left his shoes out and the sprinkler got them wet. (I had reminded him to bring them in) I simply said, "Gosh thats a bummer I hate it when my shoes get wet"

I have eaten a ton of humble pie over the years. I used to say "My child will never do that!" HA HA on me! Pick your battles...don't get hung up on the silly stuff or what others might think. Handle the behaviors that really matter!

Its especially tough with a smart persistent little one, its easy to get backed into a corner with threats that you can't follow through with. Like "if you don't pick that toy up we are not going to Grandma's" Well are you really not gonna go if he doesn't do it? Only issue consequences you have time for and can really follow through with! I still have to stop and think about what I am giving for consequences to make sure it is going to be for them and not a consequence for me! Your doing a great job! He is blessed to have you as a mom! All the best!
Smiles,
S.

1 mom found this helpful

Here's the books that helped me ...

http://resources.family.org/product/d00003b.do

http://www.ezzotruth.com/ezzo-books.html (this series goes from birth - teen)

The Baby Wise one taught me how to get my son to sleep through the night by 10 weeks. They guarantee it. Mine took two extra weeks, but that's because he had a major surgery at 7 weeks old. My son slept through the night from then on, and took 3 hour naps until he was in first grade!!!! You'd be amazed at how different a child acts once they are well rested!

Have a New Kid by Friday: How to Change Your Child's Attitude, Behavior & Character in 5 Days (Hardcover)

1 mom found this helpful

A series of books changed my life.
It's the Baby Wise series by Gary Ezzo and Robert Bucknam.
Buy them, read them, take their advice!!
For example: their advice on temper tantrums is that they are sucessful only when there is an audience, so...when your child throws a temper tantrum, don't given them an audience! When the tantrum starts--walk away. I tried it, and almost immediately the tantrums go away.
I highly recommend the book series. Their suggestions are practical and they work. Best of luck.

1 mom found this helpful

1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12 (Paperback)
by Thomas W. Phelan (Author). It involves clear expectations and follow through. It stopped (mostly) the yelling in our house and this tactic still works well with our children.

1 mom found this helpful

Katrina, Your description of your son is the definition of a toddler. He is normal and sounds like a perfect two year old. Being consistent and keeping him safe is the best way to get through these next few years. The temper tantrums are part of the uncontrolled emotions of a child, helping him to learn this is not productive by ignoring the activity and yet keeping him safe. (They can throw themselves around and bump into stuff) There are many books out there, but try a used book store and get some ideas and then make them you and your husband ideas.
Common sense and alot of patience!! Don't expect your son to be a small adult, he needs gentle guidance, and he will bloom as all our kids(they are all spirited!!)have in to great people. Good luck and relax, D.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.