L.Q. asks from King George, VA on July 03, 2008
Anxiety About Kindergarten
My 4 year old daughter will turn 5 years old this month. She has never been in a daycare setting. Although we tried many times over the years, she had severe separation anxiety and I didn't see it necessary, as I worked from home anyway. Another factor, regarding pre-school, is that we couldn't really afford the prices in our area (Where we lived the price was around $165 to $200/week for the good pre-schools). In an attempt to get her interested in kindergarten, we enrolled her into a church pre-school this summer, close to where we live. I went with her for "play time" several times - 30 minute intervals 3 days a week - before leaving her for the first day. She was Ok during these play times, but very nervous and shy. She didn't play at all, but stayed with me. She did seem interested in playing and was smiling at times. The first day I left her was for 2 hours and she seemed to do fine. She cried when
I left but was smiling when I picked her up. The second day that I left her was for 4 hours and during this 4 hours she was very unhappy. The director told me that she didn't eat, drink, or even want to go to the bathroom. Upon returning for the third day, the director met me at the door (where my daughter was trying to escape and was crying) and she told me that my daughter "is not ready". She expected that we leave and did not want my daughter to try any further. She said that when she is not with me she just "shut down" and didn't want to eat, drink, etc. She said that we should have tried this 2 years ago. I told her that I did try this 2 years ago and that it was a disaster. She replied that NOW it is a disaster. She suggested that in kindergarten they would have counselors that could help my daughter with any distress or anxiety. I decided to talk to my daughter's doctor about the situation and he said that she "needs to get over it!". This may be true but I feel guilty because I feel that it is my fault because I didn't have her in preschool or daycare before this point. We really just could not afford it. I have become so distressed and feel so guilty that I have considered home schooling her. The problem is that I simply do not have time, as I am running a business from my home and am re-turning to college to finish my degree in the Fall. If anyone has any suggestions, I would greatly appreciate it. I can hardly sleep at night as the time comes closer for her to start kindergarten. I need to go get her registered this week and I dread taking my daughter to even visit, as she gets so nervous whenever we mentioned going to school.
A little about me:
I am a stay at home mom, who works from home. I have a 6 month old daughter and a 4 year old, turning 5 this month.
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
I wanted to thank everyone once more for all the responses. I had initially decided to give it kindergarten a try, but then I found out that it is a full day here (8 am to 3 pm or 9 am to 3pm). After some real soul searching and after reading some wonderful responses from some other home schooling mothers, I have decided to home school at least the first or second year. I know that many people do not agree with this, but I feel that it is the right decision for her. Just wanted to update my initial "So What Happened?". Thanks again to all.
Featured Answers
A.C. answers from Washington DC on July 04, 2008
Try researching a "Cooperative" school setting. I found one in AAco. for preschool and was thrilled with it. There has to be one around that has a kindergarten program. Lower costs in leiu of parental support/interaction/involvement. You end up having a more supportive & kind environment- especially in the separation anxiety department. I am actually the one getting ready for my own separation anxiety sending my 5yo to public Kindergarten now! The so called system is really screwy now, if you ask me. Even at 5- they are babies! All day in a foreign setting is just too much, no matter how much you prepare them. It's sad that parents are 'forced' to enroll these babies in preschool programs just to prepare them, when not so long ago- that is exactly what Kindergarten was for! To guide and prep them for grade school.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
S.O. answers from Washington DC on July 04, 2008
I think you have the wrong preschool, that's the problem, not YOU! That director sounds like a real peach! Or rather, a prune! If she has never seen this reaction before then this is either her first job or she kicks out a LOT of kids. There are things you can do to contribute to your daughter's successful separation, and it sounds like she was making a good adjustment before you were made to leave for as long as you did. Find another preschool where they will work with you more patiently and supportively, that's my suggestion. Not all preschools are created equal! Also, don't be afraid to ask about scholarships or financial support, a lot of preschools do offer some kind of financial aid. Good luck and don't let that witch get you down!
2 moms found this helpful
T.B. answers from Norfolk on July 03, 2008
Hi Layla,
I am sorry that you had to go through this. I work in day care and this is something that happens. I had children come to my class that would cry the entire time they were there, even if they were being held and cuddled. It takes them time to learn that you will return for them and is typically more heartbreaking for the parents than it is the child. I suggest that if you really want to get her used to being away from you now, that you find another part time program close by your home. I would also suggest that the first visit you make is without her so that you can see how the staff reacts to you and your concerns. Be up front with them and tell them what happened. A good program will tell you that they are experienced with this type of situation and that they will take the time to help your baby girl learn to separate from you.
If you are going to just wait till school starts, I would ask around and see if you can find some children that she will be in school with and make play dates with them. Like someone else said, it might do her some good to have someone her own age to lean on during the first few weeks of school. They will have counselors there, and also the teachers are very well equipped to help the children.
As for what the director at the church preschool said, she was wrong. You did what was best for your family. No one should look down on you for that. That woman should have been more willing to give your daughter a chance to overcome her anxiety as sometimes it can take a few weeks or even a month or so.
1 mom found this helpful
S.M. answers from Washington DC on July 03, 2008
I am sorry for your situation, I would be a wreck if my daughter was acting this way, so I sympathize greatly. However, I do think, for the most part, kids are hardier than we think, and she probably will adjust (slowly) do just fine.
The main point I have for you is that you should absolutley NOT feel bad about your daughter not going to preschool or daycare. For crying out loud - kids don't need preschool! Your child sounds sensitive and shy. You and she need some strategies for transitioning her and not bullying from anyone about how to do it - including a daycare director or a pediatrician. They both are acting very unprofessionally. Don't let anyone make you feel like you have done the wrong thing for your child by not putting her in some group setting.
First, I would seek out a new pediatrician who is helpful. Second, I would contact the school where your child will be attneding and ask to set up a meeting (even by phone) to discuss your concerns with her new kindergarten teacher or the staff counselor. It could be a matter of needing some coping skills. There is of course a chance that she has extreme ancxiety that needs professional help, but I would thank that is very unlikely. Worst case, she needs to delay one year - many very bright happy kids do that.
1) I would get her into a playgroup with kids her age and slightly older who can model good behavior in terms of seperating from a parent (that is not 2-3 year olds).
2) Work on encouraging her independence = "I can do it myself " attitude. Make sure you let her dress herself, fix her own snacks, play independent of you.
3) Talk about kindergarten, and get some books on the subject. Make a big shopping trip to go get a bookbag and some clothes.
4) Tell her how you will be spending her first day at kindergarten - "After I drop you off, I will..." Make it very concrete so she can really imagine that you are coming back for her and when.
5) See if you can have a meeting with the teacher this summer and let her visit the classroom.
I did not go to preschool, and I was very shy. I cried my first day of school. But I loved school and ended up with Ph.D, so please don't dread the worst.
1 mom found this helpful
N.F. answers from Washington DC on July 04, 2008
My son ,who is now 24 yrs old, had the same issues. I berated myself for years about how I, no matter his reaction, made him go to school ( because I had to work). So stop guilt tripping yourself. This is your child's personality, not something you did or did not do.
My son's daycare providers all had some story to tell about his reactions. Eventually he would function fine it just took forever. One example ;when he was 10 months old and in daycare he would whine constantly unless carried around. His daycare provider was very exasperated but he did grow out of it.
In first grade he NEVER ate until I picked him up in afterschool care at 5pm. His first move ,when I got there, was to grab his lunch and wolf it down because he was so hungry.
I would recommend taking your daughter to visit the school many times before she starts. Even though she is nervous about it now she will be A LOT more nervous about it if you don't take her at all.
Since she is old enough to talk and understand you should have a series of conversations about the school and about her anxiety and ways she can deal with it. It will help if you visit the school and while you visit point out things she might like to do.
She somehow needs to stop missing you and engage with what is happening there so she can forget you for a bit.
Visiting and engaging with her teachers, both of you being there and watching and your pointing out things she might like will certainly help.
I was a sensitive child with insensitive parents. It really helped for teachers to engage me even though I was withdrawn.
It got me over my fear of the situation by engaging me rather than letting me stew in my fear. On the other hand it cannot be overbearing and aggressive- there has to be some sensitivity to the student's personality too.
The pediatrician saying something like "get over it" was stupid and unprofessional.
Let me know how things go.
1 mom found this helpful
J.H. answers from Washington DC on July 04, 2008
It's hard to transition sometimes. But our childen are smart and can pick upon things. When I started the sleep training and it got hard I felt guilty. When it was my husbands night it went well. He said he just puts him to bed. I think my son was picking up the fact that I felt guilty and would love to cuddle him a little more. Every child has to go to school. Unless you home school. Some kids love school and some kids could care less. In kindergarten they do introduce the program great. One 1/2 of the week you go in the AM and the other half they go in the PM and then a full day the last day. I think it's a great transition. I think you need to start talikg positive things to her. Get her excited and not tell a soul she is nervus. Buil it up to be some fun place to be. She gets to get all these supplies and so on. I'll say a prayer right now for you guys!
1 mom found this helpful
K.W. answers from Richmond on July 03, 2008
Poor little thing! I was one of those kids who was terrified to be away from my parents as well. Shame on that daycare director for chastising you for not doing this earlier! She should be more supportive. That's her job after all! I am a former day care worker and have taught Head Start. That inconsiderate woman should have encouraged you to keep bringing your daughter to the center for a couple of hours a day to help you get her used to it. My son was also very close to Mommy when I started him in daycare at 13 months old. Poor little guy used to just cry and cry and cry from the time I took him to his class till I picked him up. I worked right down the hall, so I heard every heartbreaking second of it. After about 2 weeks they hired a new person for that particular room and she understood that he was just scared and she spent a lot of extra time cuddling and talking to him. The other kids were playing and she would let him curl up in her lap and just watch. When he got ready to play he'd get down and play but he knew she was right there. By the time kindergarden rolled around he was thrilled to go!
Are there any families in your area with kids your daughter's age? Maybe you could set up a play date with some other mom's and their kids so that when she goes to kindergarden she already knows some other kids. What about the schoolbus? Is she excited about the schoolbus? Pick one thing that really excites her about kindergarden and focus on that. It'll be something positive for her to look forward to.
Don't feel guilty at all about the situation! You haven't done anything wrong!!! It's a shame how society makes mothers feel guilty about everything! If you worked out of the home they'd make you feel guilty about not being there, and now you feel guilty because you have been there!
1 mom found this helpful
J.F. answers from Richmond on July 04, 2008
Dear Layla,
Have you ever considered homeschooling your daughter? I know you want her socialized, but, with homeschooling, that could come at a later age (in coops and sports) when she is ready.
Blessings!
J. F.
1 mom found this helpful
S.J. answers from Charlottesville on July 06, 2008
Layla,
Hang in there. I am a Kindergarten teacher and I see this every year. During open house or meet the teacher night (before school starts) make sure to let the teacher and school counselors be aware of the situation. You may want to set up a time to talk to the teacher before the school year starts since it is often hard for the teacher to give you individual attention at open house. You may want to give your child a tour of the school before it opens so that she is familar with the school (and you can also take pictures and make a book if that gets her excited - plus she can show it off to family and they can get excited with her). There are TONS for books about starting Kindergarten and those would be a good place to start preparing her emotionally. Try reading the Kissing Hand by Audrey Penn, it is about a racoon going off to school and how he handles being away from her using his "kissing hand". You and your child can develop you own "kissing hand". I agree with many other posts about getting to know other children that may be in her class. I know that at some schools you can request that your child be in a class with another child so that the transition goes smoother. If your school stagger starts (where 1/3 of the class goes one day and then stays home a day or two for the rest of the kids to start, you may want to request that she come on the last day of stagger start so that she doesn't go one day and then stay home with you for several days). Also, stay strong when you drop her off or put her on the bus because she is looking to you for clues about how she should feel about this situation. If she cries give her a hug and then go. I know it sounds heartless but the longer parents hang out the longer the tears continue to flow. When she gets home play it up about how much fun she had. I know that I call parents during the first day of school (while the kids are in gym, art, etc...) and let them know how the day is going. You could request this of your child's teacher or counselor. I know that with some kids we make a chart and if they come into class without crying and try hard to be a part of the group we mark it on their chart. Rewards are decided on by child and parent. I want you to hang in there and 99% of kids are fine within several weeks of starting school. If you have any questions feel free to email me: ____@____.com.
1 mom found this helpful
Email