41 answers

Am I Wrong Here?? Please Tell Me What You Would Do

Ok so here's the story, several weeks ago we were at the home of my mother and her husband. Her husband, whom I've really only known for a yr, has 2 cats that he has had for like 8 yrs. They are outdoor/indoor cats. One of them is very friendly and the other is not. Her husband has told me that he has attacked other small children before, and I've seen him attack my 2 little cousins as well. So a couple of weeks ago, my son was sitting on my husband's lap and the cat came by and quickly attacked my son. Before we could even move, he swatted my son in the arm causing him to bleed. They are not declawed. I was very upset and so was my husband. However, we tried to remain somewhat calm and graceful about the situation. My mom's husband grabbed the cat, swatted him on the bottom, and that was it. The second issue is that my mother has wooden steps in her home that lead to her basement and I'm always a nervous wreck when I'm in her home. My son is crawling everywhere and learning to walk, so I watch him closely when I am there. When she heard my MIL got a gate for her home because she too has steps, my mother went out and bought the cheapest gate she could find. This gate does not fit the steps properly, and is very wobbly. The issue here is this my mom want's me to allow her to watch my son and my husband and I don't feel it's safe for our son in her home because she can't promise me that she will put that cats away when my child is there and she told me she will not babyproof or alter her home for my son the thing is I never asked her too I never even asked her to watch my son she gets a bit jelous because my MIL does and that's why she want's to watch him. Now she's mad at me I told her I would never keep her grandson from her and she's always welcome to see him and she could even babysit at our home but she said nevermind and that we live to far to drive to our home which is about 35 mins from her house what do I do am I wrong here???

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I appreciate all the advice I'm getting, and I hope it keeps on coming. However, let me clairfy a few things that way you understand what I am saying...First of all, my mother has specifically told me she will not keep the cats outside just because my son is there. Her exact words were "You can't control what other people do at their house". Second of all, I have offered to buy the gate that she needs for her home, and she refused by saying that "she will not alter her home for our son"...and remember, I never asked her to watch my son.

Featured Answers

I think you are doing the right thing. I wouldn't leave my child there either. It sounds like it might be a jealous thing as you mentioned. I would be gracious, thank her for the offer, but not take her up on it. It's not worth it. Now, when you son is older, you could leave him there. Perhaps you can tell her that: when he is x years old, I'll be more comfortable with it.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

no the safety of your family (children) comes first before a bruised ego, no matter who's ego it is.

3 moms found this helpful

You're not wrong and honestly here, if your mom is not petty she will get over it. At a later time you can ask her to watch the kids at your home. She is just a bit offended right now. Give it some time and pretend what she said didn't bother you and continue doing what you think is right for your son. Don't make it an issue.

2 moms found this helpful

you are not wrong. My grandmother has a dog that scratches, and she puts her in her "room" (the utility room with a doggy door) whenever we come over. My MIL never babyproofed but she has watched her on numerous occasions and never had an issue. I dont know where she gets her energy, but she just follows her around like a hawk all day.

I would tell your mother that if she wants to watch the baby very closely, baby proofing may not be necessary, but the cat being put away is non-negotiable.

2 moms found this helpful

Sounds like your mother has made her choice: She doesn't really want to watch her grandson. You MUST stand your ground. If it comes up again, tell her how it has to be for you to leave your son at her home. Regarding the cat... I have a crazy cat who will hit and attempt to bite just about anyone, but if you stay away from her, she will not bother you. She whacks me all the time, but she's been declawed. If I had a predatory cat--with claws--that cat would have been put to sleep long ago.

2 moms found this helpful

I don't think you did anything wrong. Your baby's safety is your priority! Cat scratches can be really bad---they can lead to cat scratch fever and major infection (I worked at an animal clinic for 10 years).

If she won't keep the cat out and baby proof her house then she has no business wanting to keep your child. My MIL wants to watch our son but their house is nowhere near being baby proofed (she even has outlets with no covers)and we have to keep a close eye on him when we are there. We don't let her watch our son.

2 moms found this helpful

Well, as far as the cat goes, ask them to put the cat outside when you get to their house. Problem solved. With the gate, buy them a new one that YOU like and trust. Problem solved. Childproofing....why doesn't your husband bring along some baby proofing stuff and put them in himself? Problem solved.
It seems like you are having a hard time communicating with them. Your mom can't read your mind. You have to ASK for what you want and express your concerns in an adult, non-confrontational manner. I understand your concerns. You aren't crazy to want what is best for your son. But think about it this way....your mom raised you. (Unless there is more to the story). You are ok. Your mom wants your child to be safe. Honestly, we did the bare minimum of "baby proofing" at our house. Our kids are fine.

Edited after response:
Well, thanks for clarifying. I guess you just can stop going over there. Don't let this be YOUR problem. If she wants to make the effort, then she will.

2 moms found this helpful

No you weren't wrong. Your son's safety should come first and as long as you tried your part by offering to buy her the gate, etc., there's not much else you can do. Just don't get defensive and be extra nice to Mom saying you appreciate it but you're concerned for your son's safety b/c he gets into everything. Maybe remind her of how she probably was when you were your son's age. Hopefully she'll remember and understand.

2 moms found this helpful

You aren't doing anything wrong. I'm sure you've done this, but calmly express to your mom why she may not babysit her grandson in her home (cat attacks, rickety gate, etc.). Let her know that when these issues are addressed (new gate, solemn promise that the cat will remain outside or locked away for your son's visit), then she's welcome to babysit your son in her home. In the meantime, she may spend all the time she wants with him at your home or at a neutral spot.

If she doesn't agree to any or all of the above, you'll know the issue is not about her seeing your son, but about her selfishness. If she drives competently, driving 35 minutes to see her grandson should not be that big a deal. Frankly, it's her loss if she doesn't make the effort. You have every right to protect your child, even if it's from your mom.

BTW, is your mom a competent driver? If so, then why is it ok for YOU to drive to her place, but she can't do the same? I'd love to hear her response to that one.

Hang tough, sister. Stand your ground on safety and stay out of the grandma "one up" wars. My mom has been battling this with my mother in law since I had babies. The sad part is she's the only one fighting this. My mother in law doesn't engage and I stay out of it. It's hard to fight by yourself.

Good luck.

2 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.