M.H. asks from Albany, OR on November 20, 2006
Advice Please - Albany,OR
My almost 5 yr old has never really left the terrible two's and I am to the point I feel like it is not her fault. I am now starting to think she has adhd. If anyone has a child or children with this disorder could you please let me know how you knew it was this and not just a bad child.. I can't hardly deal with her anymore she is making me crazy it has gotten to the point that she dislocated her 5 mo old sisters arm (playing with her). I have tried every type type of discipline, from hugs, time outs, taking away toys and even spanking her. This last week we went to Disney on Ice with some friends and she kept asking me if we could leave because she didn't want to sit there anymore. I don't like thinking of her as the bad child, I really do like spending time with her when she is not tearing things apart. I am to the point I dont think this is just her being bad.
2 moms found this helpful
Featured Answers
L.G. answers from Sacramento on November 22, 2006
Hi,
You should get her evaluated. My nephew has ADHD and he was doing things like not listening, not paying attentions, short attention span, poor little guy couldn't stay still long enought to eat, he lost interest in things quickly so he seemed and his actions seemed to be defiant which wasn't the case at all. He was evaluated and put on medication, my sister-in-law looked up ADHD and the medications and chose what she thought would be the right one for her son. I hope this helps.
: )
1 mom found this helpful
N.R. answers from Seattle on November 21, 2006
Have you talked to her doctor about this? my child is ADD and i had a hunch that he had a learning disorder, and his attention span was not normal, but tried everything under the sun before i actually was ok with asking the doctor for help/advice when knowing in the back of my mind what was wrong.
They do have meds out to help with this that doesn't cause the kids to feel and act drugged up.
See what her doctor says.
Good luck, and remember there is no such thing as a Bad Child :)
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
M.P. answers from Portland on November 20, 2006
M., I am sorry that you are having such a rough time with your 5 yo. I read some of your previous messages and can see the frustration that you're experiencing. Yes, it is good to get information from other mother's experiencing adhd questions but what will be most beneficial is getting a professional opinion. ADHD is too complex to diagnose over the internet.
You could start with her pediatrician who will refer you to a specialist. Or you can start with a clinic specializing in child psychiatry. Another Mamasource mom took her child to Cascadia Behavioral Clinic in Ptld for diagnosis and help with her challenging child. It charges you on a sliding fee scale. There will be a similar state supported clinic in your area.
From reading a previous message from you I'm wondering if you and your daughter have developed a relationship mired in power struggles. You say that you've handled misbehaviour by taking away toys and priveleges to the point that she has nothing left. Wow! If I were your daughter I would be so angry that I'd strike out at everyone. I understand why you would use the "taking away" approach. Removing toys and privileges is a time honored and effective parenting technique. But it's not working for you. One reason that it may not be working is that it sounds like that is your main focus.
I believe, along with most experts, that this sort of discipline needs to be balanced with twice as much, or more, of positive reinforcement. Catch the child doing something right and reward them with praise and any other small rewards that works. My 6 yo granddaughter is currently excited about star stickers. She pastes them onto a plain piece of paper. She also fights with her 3 yo brother and so I was surprised last week when she asked for 8 stars so that she could give her brother 5 of them. They're inexpensive, too.
If your daughter is feeling that she has no control over anything and this is likely, letting her choose how many stickers she gets is a simple way to give her just a little bit of sense of power. Another way is to give her choices. "do you want to have a banana or an apple for snack?"
I think it's important to give a child lots of loving attention even when they are misbehaving. Or I should say especially when they're misbehaving. Everyone of us function at our best when we believe that we are the best. If we hear mostly what a bad person we are we get discouraged and either give up or fight in anger.
Acknowledging her anger and giving her an alternative way to hurting her baby sister will help her learn how to manage her anger. "It is OK to be angry. It is not OK pull your sister's arm! Here is a pillow to hit." or throw. Or suggest that when you see that she's getting out of control that she run back and forth down the hall 5 times. Say or do something funny to distract her. Instead of a time out, after she's thrown that toy across the room have a cool down corner before she's out of control, away from the noise of the rest of the house, with soft pillows and books or quiet toys for her to play with.
I'm guessing that you're feeling quite discouraged and perhaps feel that you are a "bad" mother which makes it hard for you to be calm and detached when your daughter is misbehaving. You are doing the very best that you can with what you know now. The key to success is to get more information, like going to a specialist to learn what is going on with your daughter and how to handle it, and to get more positive attention for yourself so that you feel good about yourself.
You might ask how you can give your daughter positive attention when she's misbehaving all of the time. I'd suggest set up specific times to do positive things. For example, always read to her before going to bed. I adopted my daughter when she was 6 and even tho we struggled with each other throughout the evening I always sat beside her once she was in bed and read to her once she calmed down. She was often upset and acting out at bedtime. She was my only child and so I could sit quietly for a long time. And it was while doing this that she would talk with me about the things that were upsetting her. I did this every night.
You might have to do something else. An idea is to find a time when you can devote 15-30 minutes of time each day or a even just acouple of times a week, with just her. Helpful things are to read together, rock and talk, take a walk, go to the playground. Whatever you can find to do that is satisfying to both of you. It may take trying out several different things or doing the same thing several times to find just the right fit. Since you report that she seems hyper an active activity might work best at first.
I've noticed that a lot of kids don't know how to calm themselves down and so they do appear to be ADHD. And it's no wonder they can't slow down. We live in a fast paced world and many adults can't slow down. You have 3 children. You probably don't have much opportunity to just sit and be quiet yourself. Spending that time focused just on your daughter will be helpful for quieting yourself too. It will take time to develop a peaceful satisfying experience.
YOu're a single parent and so doing this will be especially difficult. Is there a way that you can arrange for someone to help you? My daughter is fortunate is some ways. Her son's father has him a couple of days a week, his other grandmother another day. And while he's gone my daughter spends time alone with her daughter and then I keep the daughter and she has time alone for herself. If you don't have family who can do that for her perhaps you have a friend. When my daughter was young, I had a friend who took her every Friday evening. And other friends who would watch her for an hour or two here and there.
Scheduling time for yourself and time alone with each child can be very difficult but it's worth it when you find that everyone is happier as a result.
I also noticed that you have a 5 mos old baby. I suspect that some, if not a lot, of your 5 yo acting out is in response to the new baby. Have you explored ways to help the older children deal with that?
My heart goes out to you. I know that you have an extremely difficult job raising 3 children as a single mom. I don't think that I could've handled more than the one that I had. The most important thing that you can do is find ways to take care of yourself so that you have the energy and patience to deal with these very active kids.
2 moms found this helpful
T.W. answers from Seattle on November 21, 2006
M., everybody has their opinion about drugs and adhd, etc. May I gently suggest going down OTHER avenues so as to avoid drugging/chemicals into your young child. Remove all dairy and wheat. It may take a few days (3 I think) to see any effect, but it would be worth the wait. My friend's son who was almost 8 at the time did a complete 180. She took the whole family off dairy and wheat (alternative milk thing was RICEDREAM Vanilla/Chocolate flavor and a rice cooker!) The next thing I know he is an altarboy at church! wow...
Best of luck!
1 mom found this helpful
M.C. answers from Honolulu on November 21, 2006
Read this book: Raising Your Spirited Child by Mary Sheedy Kurcinka. My little girl was acting in ways that did not seem "normal" to me, and after reading the book, I understand where she is coming from and have tools to deal with her behavior (and also to help her deal with her own temperment). Good Luck!
1 mom found this helpful
G.S. answers from Anchorage on November 20, 2006
Being a single mom is hard enough without all of this too. I would call the school and se if they have the resources to help test her. It would benefit everyone to take care of this now....
Hugs,
G.
1 mom found this helpful
L.G. answers from Sacramento on November 22, 2006
Hi,
You should get her evaluated. My nephew has ADHD and he was doing things like not listening, not paying attentions, short attention span, poor little guy couldn't stay still long enought to eat, he lost interest in things quickly so he seemed and his actions seemed to be defiant which wasn't the case at all. He was evaluated and put on medication, my sister-in-law looked up ADHD and the medications and chose what she thought would be the right one for her son. I hope this helps.
: )
1 mom found this helpful
N.R. answers from Seattle on November 21, 2006
Have you talked to her doctor about this? my child is ADD and i had a hunch that he had a learning disorder, and his attention span was not normal, but tried everything under the sun before i actually was ok with asking the doctor for help/advice when knowing in the back of my mind what was wrong.
They do have meds out to help with this that doesn't cause the kids to feel and act drugged up.
See what her doctor says.
Good luck, and remember there is no such thing as a Bad Child :)
1 mom found this helpful
J.K. answers from Portland on March 28, 2007
i too have a child that drives me insane lol. i haven't had him tested yet, but i strongly suspect he has add or adhd. he's not a normal hyper child, and ppl just keep telling me i need to dispcipline consistently and he'll be better. but i know ppl who discipline even less than me and their kids don't act like mine! my son sounds just like all these other children in the responses you gave, so i think that if you suspect it you should have her checked out to see. and don't listen to those who tell you you just need to discipline better or different. it sounds like you're doing everything possible and its still not making a difference. they're not bad children, they just seem to do things without realizing it...its hard to explain if you're not experiencing it first hand. good luck, and i hope everything works out either way!
1 mom found this helpful
S.K. answers from Reno on November 20, 2006
my daughter was 5 when we found outthat she had ADHD. 5 is the usual age that doctors will test them. you should have her tested and possibly have her put on meds if thats what it is..beofre it gets worse..mine daughter is 9 now..and i still have a hard time with her. when her sister was born she scrathed her on the nose and took a good chunk of skin off and slo had hit her nad left a large bruise on the side of her face and both of these were both doen when she was only a few weeks old. just for your sanity get her checked. if it is not that maybe the DRs can tell you what it is. hope this helps.
1 mom found this helpful
Email