K.P. asks from Williamstown, MA on February 04, 2008
Advice for Mother of Teenage Girl
My 13 year old daughter is very active, but quite a bit overweight. I have asked my pediatrician's advice, but she she maintains that her proportions have remained consistent throughout her growth curve. I can see her body image is affecting her self esteem and the way she is treated by other kids. Can anyone recommend a book on how to address eating and weight issues with girls this age? Any other suggestions?
Featured Answers
C.L. answers from New York on February 05, 2008
Many girls go through this phase - leave her alone! Focusing on weight will make her fat for life - just have a lot of healthier stuff in the house. I am a fat adult whose parents made weight all important - consequently I was sneaking food everywhere and all the things I wasn't allowed to eat were all I wanted. I raised two thin children who were allowed to eat everything and consequently don't find forbidden foods too exciting - I see them eating apples and clementines all the time.
More Answers
C.B. answers from New York on February 05, 2008
What she needs from you more than anything is your support. She doesn't need you telling her she is fat and her body shouldn't look the way it does. If she chooses to look into things go ahead and support that but don't push anything on her. She needs to know that she is perfect the way she is and her mother is the strongest example she can have. She needs help getting thru being a tween. Kids are cruel. They always have been and always will be. Teach her how to deal with it not change to make them happy. Best of luck. This is so hard for all mother's and daughters.
M.M. answers from Buffalo on February 05, 2008
K.,
The easiest way is to go organic. Sounds silly but everyone I know that struggled with weight and decided to transition over to organic foods is now at a healthy weight including myself. It is something the whole family can do. It is better for the whole family and isn't a diet just a change to healthy eating. The reason organic or even all natural is better for the body and help someone struggling with weight is that there are no hydrogenated oils (known to stay in the body and form fat cells and just not good for you), preservatives (also stay in the body, we can not digest them), and corn syrup ( which is just really bad for you and found in so many foods. There are others but those are the worst things for the body. Many bodies react by putting on weight. Start reading the labels so you know what you are feeding yourself and your daughter. It is amazing what they put in food that is not actually food. When your body can't digest something b/c it is not food it is stored in the body. Start giving her a daily multi vitamin if you are not already and try to buy as much organic as possible.
Two stories of how switching organic has affected my life and someone I care about. I was never really overweight but towards the end of high school always had an extra 10 lbs. When pregnant with my first child I had started transitioning to organic food. I had started out 20 lbs overweight when pregnant and only gained 14lbs during pregnancy. After birth I lost the 14 I had gained instantly and was 20 lbs lighter than before pregnancy all b/c I was eating organic food. Again after having my second child I went right back to my previous weight, but still thinner than when i was in college. I accredit it all to eating healthy organic food. But I still eat my carbs, mac and cheese etc, daily. But it is all natural organic mac and cheese. I believe all b/c I am not putting artificial foods in my body on a regular basis. Oh and I don't exercise which i would like to but at the moment don't have time. You shouldn't be overweight b/c you don't exercise especially at 13..
The other story is my brother's girlfriend was 50lbs overweight and lost it in 5 months after switching to organic food. SHe continues to eat organic food and a year later has kept the weight off. She had been 50lbs heavier for years.
Hope this helped and hope you make the transition to organic food. It is more expensive but worth every penny. A healthy life.
S.M. answers from Buffalo on February 05, 2008
It's not specifically for teenagers, but I like Dr. Oz's book You: On a Diet because it describes what happens to your body when you eat, how things are processed, and what gets stored as fat. There are a lot of cartoon pictures of organs to make it easy to visualize. Another great book is The Best Life Diet by Bob Greene. Both books focus on how you should treat your body so that your body is working for you in the best way, and not about dieting. Good luck.
D.D. answers from New York on February 05, 2008
I am certain that what you want for your daughter is to be happy and comfortable with herself. The only way this will occur is if you are comfortable with her. Unfortunate the images that we are exposed to everyday through all the media devises is the perfect size -0. My only suggestion is not to focus on the weight but on the interest that she has. Build on her interest and less on her weight. Activity such marital arts will help with self esteem and physical work out, swimming, softball, tennis, dancing are just some of the things she can do. I was the mother of an over weight daughter, the one thing I learned that I can share is that your daughter will not loss weight until she wants to loss it. As in the case of my daughter she was heavy during her tweens and teens, she had super self esteem and still does. She decided at 18 to loss weight on her own. She has never gained the weight back even after having two daughters of her own. Don't focus on her weight, focus on how amazing she is.
D.K. answers from New York on February 05, 2008
K.
Excess Weight is an inflamation. Increase her intake of Omega's to 4 per day. Careful of where the fish oil is originating and that it is from Cold Water Mercury Free Fish. I have some recommendations for you if you would like. Just email back and I will help you further. Dieting is not the answer, diet's don't work-lifestyle changes do. There are some gentle approaches you can offer without crossing the line into "depravation"
Best of luck
D. K
V.S. answers from New York on February 04, 2008
Please do not nag her or let anyone do the same. Tell her she looks the best, get her clothes that make her look good. Remind her she is your daughter and you are proud of her always. Give her all foods, control the proportions, work out a meal plan in private and signals for you to convey to her which are just in between you both. So that never in front of others she will be subject to humility, while remaining conscious of what goes into her mouth.
As a mother daughter team join a fitness program that u both will enjoy doing together, this way you can improve things together while staying positive.
M.T. answers from New York on February 05, 2008
Hi K.. I don't really have a book recommendation for you, but perhaps your daughter's phys. ed teacher would have some suggestions for you.
If she has always been overweight, and if you can honestly say that her eating/activity habits aren't those that would lead to a weight problem, I agree with the suggestion of consulting an endocrinologist.
I know that you said she's active, but that could mean a lot of things. I'd be sure that she's getting some fun physical activity daily and that her tv and computer time are limited.
I know that another member said to control and monitor everything that she eats, but I have to respectfully disagree with that advice. She should be learning to make good food choices, and having a daughter who is almost 13, I also know that it's not possible to monitor everything she eats - in the middle school cafeteria, kids can buy their own snacks, trade things with friends, she is at Girl Scouts, 4H, gifted writers group, is a set designer for the school drama club, in ski club - and I can't control what she eats there. Your teen is probably places where you can't control if or what she eats, too.
I think the best thing is to educate your daughter, and keep yourself educted. Don't keep things in the house that are full of fat and no nutrition. Read labels carefully - I picked up a box of granola bars in the store the other day and discovered that they have 14 grams of fat each! I'd limit things like fast food, soda, etc. but I wouldn't make all treats completely off limits because that doesn't teach reasonable lifetime eating habits, and I've seen where parents don't allow any junk food and it leads to bingeing or sneaking food (my almost 13 year old's best friend falls into this category)
Good luck! I know this is a really challenging age.
K.T. answers from Binghamton on February 05, 2008
hello,
for one-go to another dr. it shouldnt matter that her weight has stayed the same if she is even a little over weight theres an issue. most drs (there was an article on msn.com about this topic about a month ago) arent using the language they need to or caring enough to help our youth.
I have a friend whos mother berrated (im having a misspelled day im sorry) her for not being perfect like her sister and now she is over weight and eats because she isnt "loved". her dr told her mom that she was just "big" so she was never helped.
ok sorry about the rant i just get heated over the topic.
try joining your local Y-the family rates are usually very reasonable and then the whole family can get in on the activity. if thats out of your price range institute a family walk every night no one is exempt. try to get everyone involved so then your daughter can see that everyone needs to be fit not just her. work on portion controll-i know its (sorry for the phrase but it fits) beating a dead horse but i have seen it work my husband lost 40 lbs by portioning and moderate exersize.
dont give up,
hope this helps,
K.
Email