43 answers

Advice About Trying for a Second Baby

Our son is 28 months old, and we have been trying to have a second baby for 20 months now. I have even been on Clomid for the full run that I should be able to use it (6 months), and I now want to quit trying. A little history--I had my son at 36, and had never wanted any children before. In fact, I told my husband-to-be that I didn't want kids on our first date. He really wanted 2 and is a great stay-at-home Dad today, and although he never pushed me, I eventually came to consider having one. That little boy is the absolute love of my life, and although I was VERY uncertain even through the pregnancy, I am thrilled that he's in my life. I never even considered a second until we talked to so many people who had been only children and who told me how lonely it was. Although I didn't want a second, my husband did, and I thought it was best for my son. Plus, I knew that even though I didn't really want to do this again, I would love baby 2 just as much as my little boy. I wanted them close in age, though--first no more than 2 years apart, and then no more than 3 because as I see it, the bigger the age difference, the less the reason I was using (to have a sibling for my son) makes sense. So, I'm at the point where I would also probably need to consider invitro soon, and I don't want that. Finally, with my age of 38 and my husband's of 43, I don't know that I want to have a second now. Everything in me wants to stop, but my husband doesn't really want to, and I feel this great guilt about my son. I can't bare to think that I could have done something to make his life better but I chose not to for selfish reasons. I would value some opinions on this subject. Thanks.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

I can't help you make a decision but I will tell you this...I am an only child and wouldn't have it any other way! Happy growing up-no competing for my parents attention and no constant fighting with sibling(s) (which all my friends had to deal with). No problems in school, work, or married life. And although my husband and I wanted no children we have one and she's also an only child.

I am an only child. I loved it and still do. When each of my parents died, it was a lot of work and stress and it was all up to me to take care of everything, but that made me a very strong person and led me down paths I never would have traveled and I ended up in a good place. My life has been full of wonderful friends and I have created my own family as an adult. And, just because a person has a sibling, it doesn't meen they love and support each other through their lives, it's just as possible that they can't stand each other as adults.
Only children are smart, independent and adaptable. I have one child and am not planning to have any more.

More Answers

Hi M.,
I do not think that you should feel this great guilt. If you are having so many reservations about having a second, then you probably shouldn't. Invitro is costly as I am sure I don't have to tell you that. I think that if you really are certain about wanting/having a second, then go for it, but it sounds as though you don't want to and that is FINE! I don't think that only children have it rough, maybe they get a little lonely at times, but there are plenty of playgroups and activites to keep your little one busy and plenty of ways for him to make friends. From the way it sounds, you took a huge leap in having one child, if you are content with only one, then you should be happy/proud of that and not sad or guilty about not wanting more. It's tough because your husband wants to keep on trying, but I think you both just have to sit down and have a serious talk about it and just be grateful for the one child you have. I do have two children and I had a whole lot of mixed emotions getting pregant with my second, I love her dearly, but during my whole pregnancy I was pretty miserable. I too, said I wasn't sure if I wanted children when I got "older" however my first child was not planned and I had her at 19 and had my second @ 23. I am happy to have both of them, but I know I would never have a third. I never had the thoughts after having my first child that if I didn't have another one that she would be lonely, I knew her life would be wonderful whether she had a sibling or not. I wish you the best of luck in this situation.

1 mom found this helpful

If you are trying for a second baby that you don't want, you should take a breath and stop trying while you sort out your feelings. I was in a similar situation - Clomid, getting older, etc. I was eventually successful and had a beautiful baby boy. He is now 19! We weren't sure about a second child, and we went back and forth a lot.

While I can't tell you whether you should go ahead or stop for good, what I can tell you for sure is that you do NOT owe your child a sibling! Do not listen to anyone who tells you that single children are lonely. In fact, I don't use the term "only child" because it sounds like that child is deprived - he isn't! He's a singleton. What you child might miss in "company" he gains in independence. He might not have sibling companionship, but he also avoids sibling rivalry. He doesn't need a sibling to learn to share - that comes in preschool and playgroups and life experience. My son has learned to find and make friends in all kinds of settings - he made friends in the neighborhood and through playgroups (we found some through the Newcomers Club but there are lots of other ways). When we went on vacation, he made friends with other kids on the beach. He learned to interact with all kinds of other people, and has always been a social kid. He developed confidence, leadership skills, and an outgoing personality. At the beach, he would take a clear plexiglass container and collect crabs and fish and other items, like most kids do - but he developed such an elaborate "habitat" that other kids gravitated to him - friends came to him, is what I'm saying. He would build castles and dig trenches to the water's edge, and soon other kids would join in, and he sat there like the master engineer, directing operations and getting other kids to gleefully join in.

He is not selfish or deviant or lacking in anything. We hiked in the woods and caught frogs/toads, inspected lichens on rocks and fed carrots to the neighborhood horse. We took him to museums and enrolled him in playground programs, preschool, soccer, etc. And not a million things at one time either - when he was in elementary school, he went to religious school and was allowed to have one other activity (sometimes it was soccer, once it was basketball - not an activity every day!). We said "no" to him even if we didn't have another kid for him to share with - he didn't get everything he wanted. When he was about 9, he started helping neighbors out by bringing in their mail when they were away, putting out their trash, walking their dog or feeding their fish - whatever. He grew into bigger jobs, mowing lawns and spreading bark mulch. He started his own little entreprenurial business, built a customer base, and even learned how to do invoicing. He was recruited by more than a few colleges because of his independence and initiative. He developed into a terrific track star with the help of a great coach who saw his independent spirit and maturity, and he became a team captain because of his ability to lead. All those years digging in the beach sand turned into an ability to lead 125 guys on a track team!

He's not a miracle - just a great kid who made the best use of his particular situation. With the right guidance from 2 older and experienced parents, your son can do the same thing. I doubted myself a few times but I can say with the wisdom of hindsight now that we absolutely did the right thing for us. Families come in all shapes and sizes. You do not have an obligation to put yourself through further medical experiences to satisfy someone else's idea of what a "perfect family" is. Having one child does not mean you are a failure in anyway.

If anyone said to me, "You have JUST the one child?" I said, "He fills my life with love and joy." If they said, "But won't he be lonely without a little brother or sister?" I said, "No I don't think so at all. He has lots of loving people in his life." If you say it often enough, you will convince yourself.

It's a lot like people who have no children - others ask if they are selfish or infertile. Nobody's business, and it might not be either!!! If you have a backbone, and if you have confidence and self-assurance and a real purpose in your life, you will come to see that any family size, arrangment, lifestyle and values can work if you believe in yourself.

And the people who say you need 2 kids have also heard from others that they should have 3, and those with 3 have heard "Why not have 4?" What about those with 3 boys who have been asked "Are you going to try for a girl?" Let's all treat each other with a little more kindness, and not put our doubts on others. Mostly, people who say you need a 2nd child are trying to justify their own decision to have 2, or are not able to see that what's right for them might not be right for you. For every decision, there are advantages and disadvantages. People with 10 kids find that their kids have lots of playmates and also that they have lots of babysitters, but it's also hard to find an activity that everyone can enjoy together, right? So it's really about finding the right balance for YOU!

Stopping with one child doesn't mean you don't have enough love in you for two, or that you are selfish, or that you are incapable. It means that one is right for you.

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful

I can't help you make a decision but I will tell you this...I am an only child and wouldn't have it any other way! Happy growing up-no competing for my parents attention and no constant fighting with sibling(s) (which all my friends had to deal with). No problems in school, work, or married life. And although my husband and I wanted no children we have one and she's also an only child.

Just because the age difference between your children could be 3+ more years, that doesn't mean trying would become pointless. I have a sibling 7 and even 10 years younger than me and I love it. I personally don't think you should give up but having another is obviously not going to make you very happy. It doesn't sound like your heart is in it at all and that will not be fair to your son, husband, and future child. You can't plan everything...age difference...time it will take to get pregnant again...etc. Plus, there are plenty of only children that are very happy with their lives and grow up that way. Ask the other moms who have only children.

M.-

I am sort of in your shoes. Except that I really do want baby 2. I am a little older. . . 42 and so is my husband. We have been trying for a while to get pregnant and after 18 months or so I just had a miscarriage. I have done a lot of soul searching and really know that I want number 2. My husband is a little less clear. He could go either way. . .

Anyway, I think having another child for your son's sake is not a good enough reason. You need to feel clear about this is your heart. Perhaps your lack of conception is your inner self (soul) manifesting it's intentions or needs. No judgement here. . . just my perspective.

If you decide that you really want another baby, you may want to do a systemic body cleanse and take some supplements that enhance your fertility. I have been taking something called pregnancy prep by vitanica, but there are several different things out there. . . something called fertilitea that a friend swears by.

There are more natural alternatives that are gentler on your body and pocketbook than in vitro.

I hope this helps.
Good luck to you. It is a hard choice that faces you.

Mara

My children are five years apart and are very close. They are currently 4 and 9. They are both boys and play a lot with each other. I didn't have my second child until I was 43. I was sad when the second one didn't come along as quickly as I had hope. However, I think the age difference has been fine and in fact they do not compete against each other since they are in very different stages of growing up. My younger son tries to be like his big brother a lot and that make my older son feel good. Another thing is we were able to give both of them time as babies and preschoolers that I am not sure we would have been able to with two close in age.

Now that I have my wonderful sons and their age differnce I wouldn't have done it any other way.

Hi M., I understand your concerns I am also in the same boat. My son is 5.5 and due to severe allergies as an infant into the toddler years, which are now under control, we have decided on baby #2. I am 36 and was pregnant with #2 until I miscarried at 6 wks. I was so excited when I was pregnant, now I have the same concerns you mentioned all over again. My son loves other kids and babies it's not fair to him and breaks my heart when he asks when the baby is coming. We told him too early. My advice, stay strong and don't make yourself crazy about it. It will all work out. Good luck
M. W.

Hi there,
Here is some advice from the other side. I am an only child and am happily married for 10 years. I had 2 miscarriages before having my daughter who is 4. WE thought very hard about having another one. My husband has a brother and thinks it is an important relationship, but we are both very happy with our family as it is now. As an only child, I was never lonely. I adored my parents, we did a lot of fun stuff as a family and I had many friends and relatives. I do remember as a child asking for siblings but I also understood that my life was pretty great as it was. My daughter will also ask for a baby occasionally but when I point out that this is our family and it is perfect as it is, she seems to understand. I think you have to make a decision that makes everyone happy, but giving your son a sibling is actually a bad reason for having a child. You need to want to have this child as well. I am sure you would love it, etc...but there are no guarantees that as they grew they would even like each other. There are many siblings who do not even get along as adults and the sibling just causes the other person a lot of grief. My 2 cents.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.