L.Z. asks from Winchester, MA on July 11, 2006
Advice About Communicating with Daycare Teacher
I have a son of 15 months old and a daughter of 4 yrs. My daughter was so easy and good in all her 3 years in daycare, and all we heard from the teachers has always been how great she is. My son is a completely different story. Ever since he was transfered to the toddler room about a month ago, I was told that he is very aggressive. I noticed at home too that sometimes he grabbed toys from his sister's hand or even tried to bite her (he seems to be teething most of the time). As parents, we have tried our best to watch on him and let him know that is wrong.
Now the teacher in the toddler room is very different from other teachers I have seen in the daycare. She kept telling me that she never held a toddler, because they are not supposed to be held anymore according to her. She also noticed that my son likes to take other kids' toys, and the tone she is talking about it made me really embarassed. Honestly I am not so fond of her, therefore I seldom talk to her much as I used to do with all the other teachers of my kids. (One other reason for that is whenever I asked"how is he today?" her answer seems always the same"fine", then nothing more. Therefore, it makes no sense asking everyday) But I do want to tell her that I think that sometimes even big kids need to be held or cuddled for a bit, when they are sad, tired or sick, but I am a little afraid that I will give her a wrong impression if not saying it properly. Plus, I don't like to let people feel bad by confronting them with disagreement face to face. So, what should I do? My son now hates to be put in the car in the morning, even though i am still told he is fine during the day, I am worried.
Should I switch school? Or should I talk to the director?(I did not do that because I am afraid that it will not be easy for the director to confront the teacher either, if that is the case, I am actually causing some trouble for the director, right?)
Thank you for any suggestions,
L.
So What Happened?™
Hi Everyone,
First I want to say "thank you" from the bottom of my heart to all of you. I did not expect to get so many replies. I am truly touched, and only by reading all of these advices from you guys, I felt much better knowing I am not the only one who felt upset about this and there are so many moms out there supporting me.
I did go to the daycare one hour earlier yesterday afternoon trying to schedule an appointment with the teacher. As a side note, we moved to Dupage county four months ago, and my kids were at YMCA childcare in Evanston before. Before we came here, I spent quite some energy and time picking a daycare for them , overall, I personally still believe the current daycare is a relative good one, although there are some different settings in this center that we are not used to (One example is the morning combining of the toddler and infant room, which in my opinion, results in more chances for younger kids spreading some contagious disease. But, since it is a center with only around 10 kids below 2, it is reasonable in a way for the center to do so when the attendence is low, right? The bad part is that my son has been sick for almost 6 weeks altogether in this 4-month period :( ). On the other hand, my older one likes it and has made quite a few very good friends. That is part of the reason why I do not want to rush to switch school if everything can work out.
Anyway, It turned out that the teacher happened to have some time to talk with me when i got there. I asked very nicely about when my son's biting and grabbing toys from other kids started, what does she do to help him. I also told her about this difficulty in the morning lately in putting my son in the car. Her reply to the first question, I have to admit, is perfect to me. She usually stops him from it, takes him away and sits with him on the floor. She then uses her clear voice to tell him that is not right and she tells him to give the victim kid a hug to show he is sorry. According to the teacher, my son always understands and goes up to give a hug. I don't know whether this is really the way she does it, but anyway I told her that I think that she did great and I am doing the same except for the "hug" part at home too. I also said that I hope we can work together to help my son go through this stage. She also said that my son has learned from other kids to throw himself onto the floor-- a temper tantrum as 2's, (which he does too at home occasionally,) she usually tells him"you are a big boy, stand up", and according to her, he always gets up and walks away. This part is something I never tried, so I do not know whether it is really as effective as she described. As for the morning crying, her answer was very unexpected, she said her daughter (over 2 yr-old) does that too lately, and she does not know what 's the reason. Therefore, I got no comment on any possible reason why my son does that. Morever, I asked about the "holding a toddler" question. She said that she did not mean she never held a toddler, like when someone is crying, hurt, she would hold. I asked her about my son, how often does he want to be held. She said that he seldom asks to be held and that is why she does not necessarily hold him everyday. But if he is sad, she said she would hold him.
Another coincidence was that i met the director in the hallway before entering the room, and was told by her "Peter(My son's name) is such a happy baby, he is just always so happy..." So, maybe my son is happy most of the time and does not need too much attention(he is so at home when he is not sick or tired)
After talking to her, I felt a little better. Not that i am satisfied with everything, but her willingness to spend time with me already made me feel hopeful. In a way, I kept telling myself "do not judge a teacher because of her different personality from my own", but on the other side, I am still struggling in mind about how much is the truth. I guess my decision is to wait and see for some time. Like some moms suggest to me, I will try to ask more specific questions everyday to initiate the conversation. At the same time, I do want to talk to the director sometime soon to inquire about her view of my son's day.
OK, this is the update. Sorry it is another long mail. I want to give you guys the details so as to show my appreciation for all the kindly words and reassurance you gave me. Thank you again!
Best regards,
L.
More Answers
C.U. answers from Chicago on July 11, 2006
If you don't stick up for your son.........who will? He is still a baby, my daughter is 17 months and if we don't stick up for them, how will they ever learn to stick up for themselves?
Good Luck, I know you are in a hard situation!
C.
K.D. answers from Chicago on July 12, 2006
L.,
I used to be a director for a daycare center for 6 years and worked as a teacher in the daycare center for 5 years. Here is my suggestion, since you are uncomfortable talking with the teacher you should talk to the director as it is her/his job to make sure families are happy at the center. Since your son is unhappy and appears to not want to go to the center, I would ask if he could be transferred to another room with another teacher to see if this helps the situation. I would not feel bad about confronting the teacher or director, after all you are only looking out for what is best for your child and his well being. Situations like this are common and the best thing to do is make the teacher or director aware of how unhappy your child and you are. After all you are paying them to watch your child. If possible, talk to the other parents and see how they feel, see if their child is getting treated the same way, maybe this teacher is just not right for this age group and can be moved to a different class room. I agree with you, every child no matter their age, needs some cuddling! Good luck and hope this helps - stay strong and talk it out, it could only help the situation :)
K.G. answers from Chicago on July 12, 2006
L.,
You should talk to the director! I am a former daycare teacher and they need to know how their staff is handling the kids. The director's job is to make sure everything goes smoothly and needs to address any area that is not. Including behavior's of kids. Where this teacher got the idea that holding a toddler is bad is crazy! Yes you need to let them learn and explore, but no contact is a bad message as well. A child can lose their security if no one will hold them when needed. That can cause some of the attitude he may be displaying too! I feel you need to talk to the director. I am a supervisor in my current job, and I need people to tell me what's happening, cause I don't always know. So please don't feel bad saying something, it needs to be addressed!
K.
D.S. answers from Chicago on July 11, 2006
L.,
Don't worry about hurting the adults' feelings. The adults can take care of themselves. It's your job to worry about your kids and speak up for them, and to make sure they're getting the quality care they deserve.
As you mentioned, you've already talked to the teacher a few times with no satisfactory results. Maybe you've been too subtle. At any rate, it is still her fault because you pay her to be your son's caretaker and if something is not right during the day, she is supposed to be initiating a conversation with you about it. And by your son's reactions to go to daycare, something is definitely "not right". Many daycare givers give a weekly report to the parents in writing but I guess this one doesn't? Personally, I find the teacher's responses curt, and the fact that she wouldn't cuddle a child that is crying or hurt is extremely disturbing. So disturbing that this fact alone should lead you directly to the director's office. If you are not satisfied with his or her solution to this problem, move your kids to a different place. Your daughter is probably real low maintenance so issues didn't arise before but this doesn't necessarily mean that this is a good, and nurturing place.
Anyway, I sure wish you good luck in the resolution of this problem. I hope you let us know how this works out.
D.
L.B. answers from Chicago on July 11, 2006
Dear L.,
You should definitely talk to the director.
Your son is only 15 months old for god sake.
He is still a baby and he should not be stressed by somebody who doesn't know how to deal with small kids.
It is about your son and not about anything else.Our kids depent on us and on our decisions and your son is still just a baby.
Love
Lucy (mom of one 4year old hyper)
E. answers from Chicago on July 14, 2006
Stop worrying about what trouble the director may have confronting the teacher, and stop worrying about what this teacher thinks. She is there to care for your son. If she expects all children to be picture perfect, well behaved kids, then she's in the wrong business. And, for someone who believes kids his age (babies, really) don't need affection, then she's definitely in the wrong business. Take care of what needs to be done. If that's confronting the teacher to find out what her problem is, then do it. IF you're more comfortable with discussing it with the director, then do it. The director needs to know if one of his/her employees cannot handle the job, or is making it more difficult. If your son could talk, he'd tell you why he's more agressive and doesn't want to go to daycare. But, he can't. You have to talk for him.
C. answers from Chicago on July 12, 2006
L.,
I think you definitely should switch daycares as soon as possible. The first 5 years of a child is the most important of their life. It would affect their adult life of trusting others & believing positively. When what I can tell, that teacher is definitely not a right teacher for your little boy. Kids constantly need to be hugged & loved no matter how old they are. If I were you, I would switch day care as soon as possible & confront to the teacher & director of the reason why you switched. Considering yourself go to a workplace that you hate everyday and you've had enough, I think that's what your son is going through right now. May God give you wisdom on this decision!
C.
S.A. answers from Chicago on July 11, 2006
Hi L.,
It's my opinion, but I think you should definitely talk to the director. It's her job to understand where you're coming from and be the buffer between you and the teacher. You are not causing her any trouble. If anything you are helping her to see the type of teacher she has and then she can make the decision on how to handle the situation. Not all teachers are meant to be with all ages. Maybe this teacher would work better with the older children. The director needs to know this stuff. See it as being an advocate for you child. Also, let the director know that as a parent you are doing the best you can to remedy your son's behavior, and maybe she can offer some advice or tips. Work together with your daycare. If that doesn't work, then I would suggest changing schools.
Good Luck, I hope it all works out.
S.
Email