A.K. asks from Ann Arbor, MI on November 22, 2008
Ack! I Saw What My 12 Year Old Has Been Watching on Youtube!
Hey Mamas,
I was on youtube tonight watching a link sent to me by a friend. I saw that my 12 year old son had an account. We do not allow him unsupervised computer access and we have the computer password protected. Well, I logged into his account and saw that he had himself listed as 21. 'Suspicious' I thought. I found the viewing history and almost fell out of my chair. Yup, pics of nearly nude women. Well, just one woman actually. It seems he is fascinated with Ice T's wife (I kinda am laughing.....). I can't tell when he viewed the videos. I don't really know how to approach him about this. He has not gone through puberty but has started noticing girls and now has a girlfriend at school. My husband and I are very open with him about things such as drugs and sex. Are party line is that we do not want him to have sex until he is married. HOWEVER, we aren't naive and we have talked with him about condoms, etc. if he does decide to have sex. This is totally uncharted territory for us and we just aren't sure what to do. We are definitely going to discuss how dangerous it is for him to portray himself as an adult online, but that is as far as we have gotten. Any recommendations?
FYI- This is not something that we feel he should be in trouble for. I believe that it is normal for boys to be curious. I'm looking for advise- not opinions.....
So What Happened?™
Hey Mommas,
My husband and I talked to him together last night. At first, he denied it because I think he thought he was going to get in trouble:) Once we got through to him that he wasn't in trouble, he calmed down a little bit. However, I don't think he has any fingernails left because he sat there and bit them all down while we talked to him. Poor kid, I'm sure it was mortifying. Anyway, we told him that it was normal for boys his age to be curious about the female body and that he should not be ashamed about his curiosity. We talked to him about the types of videos he was watching and that this woman was not a real representation of what most female bodies look like and he needed to keep this in mind. What we did come down hard on him was lying about his age and the fact that he used his real name in the account- two BIG no- no's. My husband plans on having a private discussion with our son in the next few days about things he may be experiencing and what is appropriate and what is not. I don't think our son will be watching anything on youtube for awhile (at least not at our house) but my Victoria Secret catalogs may go missing:)
Thanks for all the advise and support!
Featured Answers
M.B. answers from Portland on November 24, 2008
I had a similar situation and with my now 19 year old son. i would just talk to him and keep it matter of fact. Let him know that looking at such things ar normal but that you do not agree with him doing it. Also ask him if he has any questions and try to answer them as best you can.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
K.V. answers from Portland on November 23, 2008
i just found my 11 year old was looking at nude pics on ebay!! i totally agree with you that he shouldn't be in trouble and quite honestly, you and your hubby are better role models for him and how he conducts his life than friends or ice t's wife!! :)
i let my son know that i saw them and i reminded him that girls are real women unlike what he's see on the internet. we talked awhile and it pretty much came down to curiosity.
i think your approach about him protraying himself as an adult on line is spot-on. if you are conveying to him the importance of abstinance and you are giving him the knowledge he needs if he chooses not to, you are doing the best you can. it's in his hands after that.
fyi, i was the last of my girlfriends to lose her virginity and i was the most knowledgable about how the body worked and what the parts where for. my mom was always open and honest with me. i think it's total denial that sets the kids up for early experimentation.
3 moms found this helpful
A.M. answers from Portland on November 24, 2008
Have Dad talk to him about his viewing activities just to be sure he's being safe. For all you know You Tube is the tip of the iceberg - just make sure he's staying out of chat rooms or whatever. As long as he's got the ground rules on internet playing you can only do your best. I'm sure your husband used the JC Penney catalog when he was younger!
2 moms found this helpful
M.B. answers from Portland on November 24, 2008
I had a similar situation and with my now 19 year old son. i would just talk to him and keep it matter of fact. Let him know that looking at such things ar normal but that you do not agree with him doing it. Also ask him if he has any questions and try to answer them as best you can.
1 mom found this helpful
A.B. answers from Portland on November 23, 2008
I think you're on the right track with focusing on the part about portraying himself as older. As far as the content... while you don't want him watching that, I feel like if you crack down too hard about it, that it might just be an incentive for him to be a lot more secretive about it. 20 years ago it would have been he and his friends stealing a playboy magazine :) I think that being moderately discouraging about the content while letting him know that you and Dad will be monitoring where he's been on the computer will help him get the picture that the important thing is for him to be following the safety guidelines regarding computer use, and that he shouldn't be looking at things if he doesn't want you to see them.
1 mom found this helpful
J.C. answers from Seattle on November 24, 2008
Good for you, A. --- I actually can only suggest that you talk - the 3 of you- and offer him the opportunity to talk either w/ your husband the 2 of them - or even with another adult if he wants ( an adult that you and your husband respect) --GOOD FOR YOU for not wanting to punish him-- you get a star.
Your lambs are very fortunate.
J.
1 mom found this helpful
K.T. answers from Portland on November 23, 2008
Personally, from what you've said, I think you're doing a great job. Like you said boys will be boys. If it's not the internet then it's a magazine or the underwear section out of the daily paper ads.
Keep doing what you're doing. Keep the lines of communication open and honest.
You seem to have a great head for the nature of things and letting him know that it's normal is important.
Good luck!
K.
1 mom found this helpful
K.H. answers from Portland on November 23, 2008
Honesty, honesty, honesty. Let him know you are aware (without totally embarrassing him). Let him know that at 12, even though they think they are totally grown up and ready for that type of viewing that they really aren't, and it's something you and dad don't want him doing, and won't allow. I would especially be concerned with him lying about his age on the site. Also regularly check the site, to see if there are anymore current visits. I'm a grandma to 9 children now, 8 of them boys, and had 3 boys myself. What makes you think at 12 that he isn't going through puberty? Most boys have already began puberty at 10-11, and by 12 are pretty well through some of it. I actually caught my oldest son at 11 (I won't type it out, but it begins with a M) in his room. He was devastated when I walked in. My twin grandsons who just turned 13, have definitely gone through puberty. It might be a basis to start a conversation, such as "I know you're beginning to have different feelings, and curiosity, but..." and I would suggest dad be the one to have the conversation with him, since he could share how he felt at the same age. I know this isn't the best advice, but hope it helps in some way. You don't want him to feel like he's weird for having done that, but you need to make him know it's not ok to be viewing that kind of thing on the computer. It's sooo normal for boys that age.
1 mom found this helpful
L.U. answers from Seattle on November 24, 2008
A. - I can't get enough of Ice-T's wife either....she has gargantuan boobs! That part made me laugh.
I am not really looking forward to my boys getting older, but here's what I would do.
Okay, first of all, it is NOT a breach of trust for you to be checking up on your son on the computer. You're his mom, that's our right.
Second, I agree that he should not be in trouble, but I think dad should probably talk to him. I know, we as women pretty much talk to our kids about everything, but it MIGHT be better with dad. Do you remember when you were a girl and you saw tampon or pad commercials and your DAD was in the room with you??? I would get SO embarassed! It may be hard for your son to talk to his mom about women, he may feel a bit more comfy talking with his dad.
(my husband just walked in so I asked him what he would do. he said that he would tell his son to find a woman with smaller breasts. :) kidding. He said he would ask WHY the boy is looking at that, and who he is talking to on the computer. he should get in trouble for LYING to you, and about his age, but not for being curious. He also brings up the point that your son may be looking at MUCH WORSE at his friends house, maybe where the rules are a little more relaxed.)
Also, you can look in a Sears/Penny's/Macy's advertisement and find women wearing a lot less than what that woman was wearing. When there's a will....
Good Luck!!! L.
Email