24 answers

A Newborn and a 10 Year Old Acting Out

I have a six week old boy and a 10 year old girl. My 10 year old has had my undivided attention all of this time and we have had a great relationship. Shortly after I became pregnant she starting rejecting me and pushing me away. For example, she doesn't want any hugs or kisses anymore which is really hard for me because she has always been so snuggly. I know part of this is just her growing up so I did not make a big deal about it. Now that the baby is here I am sleep-deprived and have post-partum depression. I have become more short-tempered but only when she is being blatantly disrespectful or defiant. She never had problems like this before. She was very easy going and obedient. It seems like she is trying to get a rise out of me and then when I react-usually just by telling her what she is doing that is not okay and what I expect her to do-she gets this attitude that lasts and lingers and builds and turns into a big ugly monster even though it started out as a smaller issue. I feel like she is trying to upset me because she keeps behaving exactly how I ask her not to and has a major attitude problem most of the time. I am starting to feel angry at her which I know is not good but the times when she is not (what seems to be) seeking out negative attention are becoming very few and far between.

Then last night after I tucked her in she became very clingy and would not let my arm go. The baby was crying and hungry and she kept whining "don't leave me, mommy." It's like she wanted me to chose her over the baby. She knows that basic needs always come first. She pushes me away most of the time but then suddenly wants my undivided attention as soon as the baby is screaming and hungry.

I am out of patience. I know she needs some mommy time so I'm taking her to the movies tomorrow without the baby. But, at the same time I don't want to give her the idea that she will get rewarded by misbehaving. I am supposed to be getting rest and sleeping when the baby sleeps but I can't do that because my 10 year old is acting like a 2 year old.

Help? Anyone? I am so frustrated, tired, emotional, overwhelmed, and I feel guilty that my 10 year old doesn't have my undivided attention anymore.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

At 10 she can understand that the baby can not take care of himself like she can so he needs you to do it for him. Explain to her that you did that for her when she was a baby and that you still love her just as much as before and she can help you with her little brother.

More Answers

Hi E.!

I've been in this position, but with my step-daughter. She was "the princess" for years and received the most attention because of her creativity and zest for life, not to mention how beautiful she is.

Then.....along came a baby boy! Yes, she would "fight" to see if we would choose her over the baby, when it was obvious that the baby was screaming and needed my attention.

This is tough, let me tell you, because what can easily happen is resentment. Your daughter can easily begin to resent your new baby, and feel "hate" toward him for "ruining" her perfectly good life!

I had to try to NEVER interrupt her to go get me a diaper, because then it would "set her off". I'm sure you know what I mean. So, then I thought, I cannot do this for the next 10 years, I have got to try something!

I decided to have a "party" for her. I allowed her to invite about 6 of her friends. The party was a "Now I'm a Big Sister" Party. Every friend had to dress like a mom going out to a fancy party (That was fun in itself to see how these girls think their mom's dress). I set a "fancy" table with champagne glasses and all. I tried to make it as fancy as I could, and as decorated as I could.

All the games were like Baby Shower Games, except I tried to "target" the work a new mom has to deal with. Like multi-tasking, who can Microwave a bottle, get a glass of Lemonade, and take out the "Lasagna" the fastest? Time them so they can see how fast they can multi-task :o) The winner gets a prize. Another game was a SMELLY DIAPER game. I bought small candy bars, and microwaved each one in a baby diaper until it melted. Then I smushed them really good! I numbered each one with a Sharpie and they had to guess which candy bar was in the diapers :o) Funny game.

Anyway, after the party, we went on with our "normal" life. I still tried to be sensitive to her, as I always was. It was HER that had come around a little. It was actually amazing. By the time our son was 2, she was a VERY proud big sister, and very helpful.

It really is just climbing over this "first hill" with her. There are alot of emotions she's dealing with. Maybe it's time to celebrate HER. If you have photos of HER when she was an infant, it would be nice to share them with her. Talk about her Shower, and the things she would do as a baby. It might help, too.

Good Luck, E.. You're in a sensitive spot. I wish you the best with your little family.

Love, N.

2 moms found this helpful

One thing I found worked really well with my two is saying "______" (insert older child's name) "I am going to nurse baby "______" (insert baby's name) now. What do you want to do while I am doing that, and what should you and I do afterward? Why don't you think about it for a few minutes, then tell me what you want to do."

This let my older daughter know that 1) I was noting that she would be left to her own devices but that I cared about what she would be doing while I was busy with baby and 2) After giving baby my undivided attention for a short while, I would do the same for her.

This has to be said ahead of time to be effective, though.

1 mom found this helpful

It sounds really challenging. A few ideas, have you tried praising her for every little even tiny thing she does that isn't acting out? It sounds like she just really wants attention and if you start giving her attention for the cooperative things she does she might gradually learn that there are other ways to get attention, like when she helps mom change a diaper etc.
Also, one on one time is probably really good idea, and she is old enough that you can talk to her and tell her that you are frustrated and want her help in figuring out ways for her to act more cooperatively with you. Sometimes if we just open up to children and tell them some of our feelings and ask how they are feeling ( basically, could ask her if she is scared that mommy is going to abandon her/not love her now that the little on is here, etc.) understand what she is feeling, and together become like a team in working it out together.
Believe it or not, most children really want to contribute and help out, they just don't know how to handle their own feelings and how to come up with solutions that incorporate everyone's needs. Just remember- she has needs too and so do you- both are really important, maybe together you can come up with a way so both are met.

good luck.

1 mom found this helpful

This can be a difficult one especially because of her age most of the time they are overjoyed at 10 and become a little mother helping out tremendously with the baby. It sounds as though she doesn't feel that connected to the baby you could try to give her some important things to do for or with the baby. She also may need more family time from her father, grandparents etc. and maybe even hanging around her friends. I would focus on her positive keep her involved in her interests and let her know she will always be your little girl but it is time to be a big sister. And mom take care of yourself this is no time to exhaust yourself over an older child if it goes on to long you may need a family therepist she is afraid she is having to give up something big (YOU) because of the baby and we know that in order to have a healthy baby their little needs come first let her know it is her time to be helpful and grow up

1 mom found this helpful

Hi E.,

I agree with Clair K. It sounds like your 10-yr-old just needs to be reminded that you still love and care for her. For someone so young words may not be enough. You need to show her that she is not being replaced or forgotten. Have someone watch the baby while you spend some time with your daughter. Maybe the 2 of you could watch a movie, shop, or share an activity that she enjoys.

It is also important to include her while taking care of the baby so that she may develop a stronger bond with her sibling. Maybe you can let her wash bottles or help you give the baby a bath. When she does help you accomplish a task, share some words of encouragement so that she feels appreciated. I grew up with a single mom and I know how hard it is to gain a little attention with 2 younger siblings.

Finally, be easy on yourself. No one expects you to be supermom. Instead, try to get some much needed alone time by calling up friends or family that you trust to watch the children. Watch a movie. Go to a spa. Take a walk. Buy some hot shoes. Whatever gives you peace. Just remember that when you are stressed out, it will only reflect on how well you treat and talk to your children.

Good luck, and may God watch over you and yours.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi E.,

Congrats on the birth of your son. This is a time to be enjoying your new arrival and sorry to hear of your frustration. Your daughter is having a hard time accepting she isn't number one anymore. Her acting out is a way for her to be assured she will get attention from you, even if it means she gets herself in trouble and receives negaitive attention anyway she can get it.

My advise, include her in the care of your son. Helping you feed him, change him, bath him, even play with him. Always tell her she is still your number one and really try to explain to her that her brother at this stage in life needs attention, just like she did at his age.

Also suggest sitting down with her and talk with her. Show and speak with her about your concerns. Just talking to her will make her realize you do pay attention to her and truly concerned. Tell her you love her very much and realize how she feels.

Lastly, continue doing one night a week where you do something with her, without your son present. As much as you need your sleep at this time, you have two kids that do require your motherly love and attention. Heck, I have a tough time giving my husband attention because my 10 week old takes up A LOT of my time and mental energy, that i am lucky I have any energy left for my husband. So I feel you!

Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful

I don't have any advice, but I hear your frustration and wanted to let you know I sympathize. I think taking your daughter to the movies is a good idea - maybe she can make a skit or puppet show for you to watch. If desired, you can help with costumes or set design. If she is involved in a project and knows you will be there to see it, she may feel less alone. I would also take time to read books aloud. It is something you can do while you are holding the baby, but doing for your older daughter. Your son won't care what you are reading, but your daughter will. Good luck.

Been there!! Please take comfort in knowing that you are not alone. :)

I find things go more smoothly when our 10 year-old is given more "Mommy Helper" status in the family. She enjoys the special attention, title, and responsibility. This way she doesn't feel like she's on equal-ground with the baby (because she's not). She reads to the baby, helps prepare dinner, and now helps with laundry and dishes. Of course, that comes with an allowance/incentives.

One thing we did recently was watch old video tapes ("home movies") when our oldest was little. WOW! Just hearing the way we talked to her when she was little...of course it's like the way we do with the baby (he's now a toddler). I let them know what it was like when my daughters were babies/toddlers and how they've grown. (We have 2 other daughters, age 7 and 5, but the challenges have been with my oldest. I think it's a first-born thing...at least in our case) Just utilize any time you can by addressing the needs of both. For example, when you're feeding the baby or taking him for a walk, have "girl talk" with your daughter.

Another huge improvement for me is trying not to react when my daughter "acts out." She feeds off my frustration, anger, disappointment, etc. We made a pact to "listen to ourselves" when talking with one another. And as long as you spell out the rewards/consequences, it will not seem to you or her that you are giving in to any misbehaving. An outing now is a great getaway, just make sure you have the time to TALK since the movies will be 1.5-2 hrs of not being able to do so.

When times are challenging, I tell myself that it won't be this way forever. And of course when times are harmonious, I tell myself that they won't be little forever. Everyone in your family is adjusting. So enjoy your beautiful children and good luck!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.