S.A. asks from Kill Devil Hills, NC on February 26, 2010
9 Year Old Is Constantly Faking Injuries
How do I handle my 9 year old son who constantly fakes injuries? In the past, he's fooled the school nurse 2 yrs in a row, pretending he was practically blind so he could get glasses like Harry Potter. Last time was his arm was hurt, so he wanted to wear a splint. I finally just let him wear one & he did for about a week, then has been miraculously cured. The latest has been an ankle injury-he really wants crutches-& has "sprained" his ankle 4 times in the last 3 weeks! He has plenty of attention, but he gets jealous of anyone who is injured or sick. His little brother was running a fever last week-all of a sudden he was sick too! I gave him the benefit of the doubt AGAIN & took his temp-of course it was completely normal.
I KNOW he's lying! He got off the bus today, limping like a 1 legged War Hero, claiming his teacher saw him fall down the stairs & then tripped over him. I told him I was going to call & ask her & said is there anything he should tell me? He stuck to his story. I DID call & the teacher said he "fell" on one stair & she almost tripped on him, but hardly even brushed him. She said she was very frustrated w/him by the end of the day because he claimed he "didn't know how to sit down on the carpet" & was disrupting the class. He never even asked to go to the nurse, but did mention the fact that as of Monday, we lose our medicaid for our boys (because we worked too hard this year & our income exceeds the limit-God Bless America, right???).
Do I baby him or make him fess/toughen up? This is a kid who swore he had a toothache last year to get out of Spanish Class. I told him if I took him to the dentist I had to pay out of pocket, so PLEASE-don't lie to me! He said it was true. The dentist took x-rays & found nothing...he was obviously faking!
We can't afford this now & I can't trust him to tell me the truth, so I need some pointers to outwit his little mind.
Thanks in advance for any help!!
A.H. answers from New York on February 26, 2010
my friends son used to go to the nurse all the time saying he was sick.. she told the nurse to just send him back to class.... also when he complained at home being sick.. she would make him lie down.. no tv.. because your sick.. couldn't go out because his arm hurt.. ... he wasn't happy because of the no tv... no playing with friends... he finally stopped doing it.. if your son doesn't stop.. talk to the school about counceling.. it may help and they don't charge you.. good luck
2 moms found this helpful
R.Y. answers from New York on February 26, 2010
My first impulse would be to to toughen up but that is kind of how I was raised. My grandparents were nurses in the old days before antibiotics so they raised my mom to be pretty tough with us. We knew if there wasn't some thing substantial (bleeding, fever over 100, throwing up, etc) we had to go about out business without special treatment other than a bit of asprin/tylenol or cold medicine. Maybe insisting on a concrete symptom other than a random part that hurts will help. If he complains have him describe the alleged pain and how it happened. No redness or swelling is probably a fake. But he can always rest it and put a cold pack on it (he can do it himself). You can also do the "Hmm, if you are sick you should be in bed (with no distractions like tv, music, games, etc)" response.
I hear you about the insurance. We have such a high deductible we are still paying for all the doctor visits. My kids are too little to even give me meaningful descriptions yet so we have been there a lot.
2 moms found this helpful
P.W. answers from San Francisco on February 26, 2010
I think you should go with it and baby him. Don't spend much money on this, obviously, but I think you should play along with it -- emphasis on the word play. Let your son know, with humor, that you know he's not really sick, with a kind of nudge and wink attitude. However, as long as it doesn't cost you anything, I think it's pretty harmless. He just wants to be babied. I doubt he'll do it in high school.
He shouldn't be getting out of classes because of it, but maybe a placebo pill or something for times like that.
And I think the Harry Potter thing is funny too, as well as the splint. I really think counseling is unnecessary when this is so obviously a ploy for being babied. It doesn't harm people to be babied occasionally. If you give him what he needs, he'll likely need it less.
S.C. answers from Norfolk on February 27, 2010
Keep track of the situations/family stuff going on when he does this...is another sibling having something special go on? Does he have a lot of homework? A test? etc. See if there is a pattern. He may have chosen this as a way to cope with something (jealousy, learning difficulty, family stress, etc.) If nothing shows then it sounds like time for your son to get some tough love. He is old enough to understand that lying is not okay. Make sure all your family members are sending that same message by being honest to him and around him. You said you have medicaid which tells me you don't have a bunch of money to pay for appointments and it is not fair for the taxpayers to foot the bill for you son's dramatics. Tell him you will have to start selling his stuff and cutting expenses (cable, video games, doing things that cost money) to cover the doctors costs. Then DO IT! Follow through. If it still doesn't stop or you do see a pattern then seek counseling. His school should be able to offer some resources. You don't want your son to grow up unable to cope with life without lying or avoinding situations by lying. Good luck.
S.S. answers from Dallas on February 26, 2010
I agree with Rachel and Julie. If he is hurt or sick, he should stay in bed with only books and homework to entertain him. I think all kids pull this stunt at some time in their little lives. When my kids tried it, I pulled out the child psychology card and said something like, " Oh, that's too bad you are hurt/ill I had planned a suprise trip to McDonald's for ice cream so I guess daddy can take your brother while we stay home." or "I planned a surprise family movie night, guess you will have to stay in bed while mommy, daddy and your sister watch a movie together and cuddle on the couch." Follow through with the surprise and don't cave in and let him out of bed, the games should stop. If it still continues after this, I would seek professional help.
M.C. answers from Washington DC on February 26, 2010
I think its an age thing. My 8y old tries this alot too. So please know that you are NOT alone in fighting this battle.
My kids do the fake fever bit too. I tell them that the thermometer is law. If the thermometer says your not sick...then so be it. They even have ones now that have a big dial area - green is ok, yellow is a low-grade; and red is really sick/high. Another way to keep him from faking sick is to tell him that the only true way to check your temp is to use a baby thermometer where the sun doesn't shine.... that SHOULD do the trick!!!
As for the faking sick with sprains, crutches, etc. My suggestion is a little bit of system shock. Talk to your local hospital/ER about doing a tour or even the Urgent care place that is near the turn off to Duck.. (I must say that your local hospital is a VERY nice one. We visited there for a whole week a few years back due to illness while on vacation.) Let him see kids that don't have a choice about whether or not they can use them.
As for the insurance issue. I'm sorry to hear this. I don't know if there is a low-cost or free health care clinic in your area or not. We have one here. There is a dentist that works out of it too. One visit there, and waiting all day to be seen for a fake illness might cure him too.
H.F. answers from Washington DC on February 27, 2010
It sounds like you've got yourself a real smart one there! I used to pull a lot of tricks to try and get out of school/class when i was younger, but usually just saying I had a stomach ache/fever. Once in a great while I might have pulled something bigger and said i sprained my ankle, etc.
I'm not sure if you've tried this yet, but what really worked and got me not to fake ill was being told that I wouldn't be able to do any of the special activities I enjoyed for as long as I was "sick".
Sometimes with a smart/tricky child, you have to be tricky with them as well. Next time he says his stomach hurts & he can't go to school, feign pity and tell him something such as - "Oh no, well this is just horrible! I was going to take you and your little brother for ______ after school, but I guess if you're too sick to go to school, I'll just take your brother by himself."
And the same formula for the various other injuries. In most cases, if it's really something the child enjoys, they will cave and go ahead and go to school. If not, well then you have to do what my parents always did. Go ahead and let them stay home, but make sure the day is not some kind of vacation. If they are "sick", they should stay in bed most of the day and rest. No video games, not a lot of tv, etc. Trust me, being confined to their room and being bored all day will get old very quick!
S.G. answers from Albuquerque on February 26, 2010
Maybe you should call and talk to his dr. I know these are fake instances but maybe his dr. could suggest a solution. What about counseling? To be honest I wouldn't even know where to start so I would call the pediatrician. They can direct you in the right place.
You have to admit, the Harry Potter thing is pretty funny! Sorry your going through this at such a crappy time. Good luck.