30 answers

8-Month-old Breastfeeding at Night

My son is 8 1/2 months old and a big boy. At 6 months (last weight check), he was over 20 pounds. He is breastfed and on solid food. He has never been a very good sleeper. When he wakes in his crib at night, he is usually screaming and extremely upset. I could never just ignore his crying, so we usually end up picking him up and sometimes sleeping with him on a chair in his room. Then when he's sound asleep, we put him back in the crib. I nurse him usually 2 or 3 times per night. By "night," I mean his night, from about 8 p.m. to 7 a.m. Sometimes he gets very upset if I don't nurse him, and other times he will fall asleep in my arms but wake up and cry as soon as he is placed in his crib unless he's nursed. After he nurses, he will usually go peacefully into the crib for another couple hours. I know he must be getting milk because he frequently leaks through diapers--I have to change him every time he eats at night. Is it okay to still be feeding a baby of his age at night? Would it be unrealistic to expect him to go 11 hours without eating? Will it affect his teeth to keep nursing at night? (He has 4 so far.) And will he ever outgrow night nursing on his own, or is it a battle I must wage eventually? Any moms have babies that did or didn't outgrow it on their own? It really seems to me like he is hungry, but I don't know if he should be at this point. I'm wondering if he would sleep better at night if he learned not to nurse. I'm also hoping to wean him around a year old but know I can't so long as he is still feeding at night. He refuses bottles, especially when he is tired. Thanks!

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

You might want to try giving him cereal right before you put him to bed. Possibly before you breastfeed him and put him down. It sounds like the milk is not enough to keep him full through the night. I didn't breastfeed, I didn't have enough milk, but I started feeding my children cereal before bedtime by 2 months old. My children never liked to sleep through the night either, as a matter of fact my 23 month old still wakes up in the night and she sleeps with her father and I. But that's the only advise I have to give. If you are already feeding him cereal maybe you need to make it thicker and give him more?

Good luck!

My only advice is to pick up the book healthy sleep habits happy child by Dr weisbuth. It will guide you to the best solution but you will have to eventually let him cry through a feeding soon to prevent night wakening habits later in his toddler years! Good luck! N.

More Answers

Hi M.!
My son is 13 months old and I'm still nursing 3 times/night. Everything I've read about the subject seems to be either black or white. On one side parents say the only way is to let the baby cry it out, nursing is unnecessary at this age, don't pick him up, just pat his back, and then he'll learn to sleep on his own. On the other side of the coin, parents say to pay attention to your baby's cues and follow them (that'd be the attachment parenting people who co sleep and nurse into toddlerhood). Incidentally, I just read that in the rest of the world it's common to nurse until 2-3 yrs, and one of our past surgeon general's (I can't remember her name) said that it is a lucky, happy, and healthy baby whose parents continue to nurse into toddlerhood. As I myself have been puzzling over the same questions you asked, I think that there's no one right answer. Every child's needs differ, as do every family's needs. What I'm going to try to do is be still for some time so I can drown out all of the differing advice, and try to follow my own mothering instincts to see what's best for my son. I'd love to talk more though if you want to exchange emails!

2 moms found this helpful

There is NOTHING wrong with a child his age wanting to nurse- night or otherwise. You should be very proud of yourself that you child still wants to nurse and can!

Don't beat yourself up- He wants to be with you- he finds comfort in your touch and presence.

Do you use cloth diapers?? You may find that if you use a good quality [not found in your local 'chain' baby store] cloth diaper and cover at night that you will not have to change him but instead be able to nurse him quietly and put him right back to bed.

We personally have a bassinet next to our bed. I'll feed the baby and many times he'll end up sleeping next to me but I usually will put him in the bassinet after he is done eating. I find that with him close like this even if I'm not nursing or holding him he will sleep much better as he knows I'm only an arms reach away. This however may not be the best solution for you.

Is there a reason you don't want him to nurse at night? Are you actively trying to wean him? At 8 1/2 months he is probably not ready to wean- also with all the changes going on with him (growing, experiencing new things, etc) it may also be a comfort that he needs. I see that you want him to wean around a year- that is still a number of months away. Do you pump and use that instead of formula---then he'll have the familiar taste and perhaps that will help.

When you feed him at night to you keep the lights off or low? Do you avoid stimulants like eye contact and talking? If you are wanting him to be able to eat and go straight back into bed you need to avoid anything that fully awakes your son- like diaper changing and bright lights and music. Slowly (could take days, weeks, etc) he will start sleeping longer stretches. Remember nothing lasts forever and each child goes through growth spurts and stages at different rates.

Visit www.llli.org and find a La Leche League in your local area. Give one of the leaders a phone call. They can talk with you about ANYTHING and give sound advice. It may also help to go to one of the local meetings--you can meet some other mom's in your area and also talk to those who have been where you are now.

If you want you can always contact me anytime- A. AT dinkerandgiggles DOT com. I'm a mother of three so more than likely I've "been there, done that" Also keep in mind---he's not going to nurse until he's in college- so enjoy this time that he does want and need you-- They grow fast and soon they don't want you- they want to be independent!

1 mom found this helpful

I'm a FTM, so I'm not sure about how this all works myself--I just do what I think is best.

My 20mo boy still nurses at night.

Yes, nursing at night can cause teeth problems. Make sure to brush them 2x a day to get out all the icky stuff.

I think if you dropped to 1-2 night feedings you would be fine. I'm all about letting my son tell me when he is hungry.

Right now he only nurses 2x at night and then right when he wakes up for the day.

If you are planning to wean at a year, you would probably do best trying to get his feedings down at night so it would be easier.

best of luck

1 mom found this helpful

It's definitely worth trying to soothe him another way if you can. However, my son is just as big and chubby and we have had the same issues with him. He still doesn't sleep through the night at 10 months. After a lot of researching and reading, I've found out that this is actually completely typical and healthy for breastfed babies (as much as we might not like it). The good news is that, at 10 months, my son seems to be starting to outgrow it. We put him to bed at 7 and he usually now sleeps through until about 3 or so, nurses, and then goes back to sleep until 7 or so. So it will get better. Keep up the good work, and try not to listen to those people who tell you to let him cry it out!

1 mom found this helpful

You might want to try giving him cereal right before you put him to bed. Possibly before you breastfeed him and put him down. It sounds like the milk is not enough to keep him full through the night. I didn't breastfeed, I didn't have enough milk, but I started feeding my children cereal before bedtime by 2 months old. My children never liked to sleep through the night either, as a matter of fact my 23 month old still wakes up in the night and she sleeps with her father and I. But that's the only advise I have to give. If you are already feeding him cereal maybe you need to make it thicker and give him more?

Good luck!

For both of my kids it was just one of those things....we went to bed and when we woke up it was morning. My husband and I both looked at eachother and asked if the other got up with the baby, neither of us had. The baby made it through the night and that was it. Both of my kids did this at 2.5-3 months old. Now my daughter who is 2 still wakes up almost every night but does go back to sleep with out anything. My son is 10 months and he sleeps 12 to 14 hours a night. I always give him a bottle before bed, and he sleeps all night. So for both of my kids they did it on there own. I don't know if maybe you could try to get him down after he wakes up the first time without feeding him again. See what happens. Every child is different, maybe he really is hungry. Or maybe the breast milk isn't enough, what I mean is maybe it doesn't fill him enough to make it 12 hours. I don't know if there is anything else you can give him. I breast fed my children for a bit, I was seriously ill after I had my son and had to stop breast feeding. He was then put on formula. I did notice that it's a little thinker than breast milk. But I don't want to offend I think it's wonderful that you completely breast feed, that was my plan too. Maybe you could pump and add a little cereal to it, maybe that would make him feel a little more full. We did that with our daughetr and for a while she slept great. Now we have a whole other issue...Night Terrors. I hope I was of some help to you. Good Luck, but I really don't think he should be needing the extra feedings, unless he really is hungry. In that case try the cereal. Good Luck
C.

Wow! Just went thought this w/ my 7 month old son. He too was breastfed and had to be rocked to sleep, woke upon hitting the sheets, woke 2-3 times a night, and refused to take a bottle. Wish I could give you an easy solution, but it was a hard 4 weeks....We had to let him cry himself to sleep, and would not respond to his cries at 11pm, 4 am. He was programmed to wake and be comforted and fed. He does not need to eat that many times.(he is also 21 lbs) We had to reprogram him, and it was a long hard 4 weeks w/ many tears from he and I. I eventually gave up breast feeding (not w/out much guilt) because he could not do boob and bottle. Formula seemed to satify him more when he took the bottle, and I dont think I produced enough. Make sure he drinks more during the day since night seems to be a big feeding time for him. I am happy to report tht he now goes to bed at 7pm after 5 min of tears (was usually a 1/2 hr)eats again at 11pm (while he is still asleep) and then wakes at 6am. We are all much happier. Good luck reprogramming your baby! You can do it and will be so much happier w/ uninterrupted sleep.

I feel your pain! I have 4 and my youngest is 8mo. old and still gets up to nurse every 3 hrs. He is my worst sleeper and it gets very frustrating. Part of it is maturity, the other part is training. I KNOW how hard it is to let them cry, I did it with my other 3 and it took no time at all for them to learn to sleep on their own, but I am having a hard time letting Alex cry. A couple of weeks ago I started putting him down for his nap while he was awake (but VERY sleepy) and the first day he cried for 15 min. the next 5 min., after a couple of days he started going on his own to bed at night. It is hard to hear them cry, but if they are safe and dry and fed then you know they are ok and it is just temper (yes, temper even at this early age). Now that he is use to going to sleep on his own I am going to leave him be if he wakes up to nurse 3 hrs. after I put him down. I know from his eating habits that he can go MUCH longer than 3 hrs. b/t feedings. That part it training, the longer I get up to feed him every 3 hrs. the longer he'll keep doing it and the madder he'll get when I don't do it. I know from experience what I need to do, but I am having a hard time doing it with this one. Alex will not take a bottle either or a paci and my husband helps all he can, but now it's time for me to deal with it, it its hard, but trust me-it is SO nice when they are finally trained. Grab some tissues, turn up your music or go outside, but hang in there. My oldest daughter only cried for 30 min. 1 night and that was it, so take heart and hang in there-sleep is a beautiful thing for both of you! Good luck-
G.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.