K.R. asks from Greensboro, NC on October 24, 2008
5Th Grader in Love Already?
Good Morning Ladies,
Well, I did it. I gave in and let my 11 year old, 5th grade, son have an email address. Right out of the gate this girl in his class started emailing him about 6-10 emails daily and she has a cell phone already. My son is a great student and very trustworthy, at least until now. Not that he is doing anything really wrong(other than growing up which i don't like), it's just that he is always jumping off the computer every time i walk in the room. I told him we have access to and will read his emails from time to time and that we trust him but the internet is a very dangerous place and we want him to be safe. Well, they have already sent I "heart" you's back and forth and he asked her to go to the movies and hasn't talked to his dad or I about it yet. Not sure how he plans on getting there. I just feel like he is sneaking around and it bums me out that he feels he can't come and discuss this with me. I'm in search of some good books about how to talk with your kids about such subjects. I try and he just doesn't say much. I want him to feel comfortable coming to us and sharing his feelings, just not sure how to approach it without putting him on the defense. I want to have a conversation not just me talking. Also need to bring up the birds and the bees too. Looking for any insight or good books to better myself and help my children grow(just not grow up, ha ha). Thanks
More Answers
L.J. answers from Lexington on October 25, 2008
If his computer is in his bedroom, I suggest putting it a public area of the house. Do that with all your children so he won't feel singled out. We let our oldest have a computer in his room and it got to be sticky, like what you're facing. A public computer helps with that.
Also, you can have parental controls put on his email, can't you? I've done it through both Yahoo and AT&T. Once in a while I get a notice about my 13-year old. Then I can talk with him about it.
Do you have a Facebook account? I wasn't going to get one, but it was my 15-year old's idea. It also helps me keep tabs on them, just a little. One day my 13-year old IM'd me from school when he was supposed to be doing computer work. We talked about that. I can also see who his friends are. I know most of them already, but it does help.
Finally, you and your husband (or just your husband) may need to talk with him about relationships. He probably has learned much of the "mechanics" from school and friends, but the best place to get the real-life human perspective is at home.
Keep the lines of communication open--and I know that's not always easy. My oldest is 26 so I've been doing this for a while. A good place to talk to your son, btw, is in the car, because he doesn't have to look at you. I read this somewhere when my oldest was his age, and it works.
3 moms found this helpful
P.M. answers from Wilmington on October 25, 2008
In LOVE in 5th grade??? What will these children be doing in high school if they start the holding hands and little love notes at 11 years old?
I have boys 15 and 16 and have experienced parents who thought it was "cute" to have their fifth graders "going out" as the parents drove them to the movies. I think we push our children a little to fast to grow up and the internet and cell phones make it easier. The family phone is not longer in the kitchen where parents can monitor conversations and the computer opens up an unprotected world for our children.
I have found to help boys open up and talk, you need to engage them in some activity. Moms are used to sitting and having conversations with friends and family; with boys get them to do something and then engage in conversation....go for a walk, build with Legos, etc.
As for the computer....move it to a central place in the house and since you already told your son that you would be checking emails, be honest and let him know you will be checking and is there anything that he should let you know? Give him the opportunity to tell you first.
Good luck.
3 moms found this helpful
D.B. answers from Charlotte on October 24, 2008
Hi K.,
I have two boys, one of which had an overseas email friend (who was a girl) for about a year before they got tired of it. (No I "hearts" you or anything.) He was in the 9th grade. The frequency of emails was around once a week or so. If the girl had emailed my son anymore than that, he probably would have ignored her because he didn't want it to be serious. He told me that seriousness with a girl was too "distracting". Quite honestly, I'm glad about that - I'd prefer for him to start dating when he's a junior or senior. (Oh, by the way, as an edit, I should add that I read every email they sent to each other, and my son knew it.)
Your son and that little girl are doing some grown-up role playing right now. If I were you, I don't think I would put up with my son getting 6 - 10 emails a day from this little girl for long, because this kind of role playing is for older teens and borders on her being a little obsessive where your son is concerned. There are lots of other things your son needs to be paying attention to right now. There's plenty of time for paying a lot of attention to a girl later.
Would you consider calling the girl's mom to meet for coffee? Ask her when you are face to face if she knows her daughter is emailing so often. Take her copies of the emails to show her if she doesn't believe you. Tell her that you are sure she has a lovely daughter, but this kind of relationship should be for when they are both older. Could she help with that? Tell her you will try to keep your son from emailing so often as well. (Don't tell her that her daughter is obsessing over your son - you don't want to make her defensive.)
Most likely she will try to put the breaks on her daughter. We mothers of boys have to be really careful that our boys don't make stupid mistakes that can land them in the court system. I've not had any problem with that in my families or friends, but you read about it in the paper and hear it on the news. Certainly girls get the bad end of the stick with teen pregancies, but boys can have charges set against them for having sex with a minor. Those charges will stay with them all their lives as a criminal record. Maybe we as parents don't think about this side of it - we just don't want the girls to get pregnant or any of them to catch an STD. But life is more complicated than that, and we really do have to be vigilant. In your case, it doesn't matter that the little girl is doing most of the wooing, K. - if something were to happen, her parents would lay all the blame on your son. That might not be fair (there would be blame on both sides) but that's not the way a girl's parents see things.
The ladies who mention never having a computer in the bedroom are spot on - also make sure you know how to access deleted emails so that you can monitor what he would rather you not read.
If your son is not in adult chaperoned after-school activities, now may be the time to enroll him. After school swim lessons, music or sports he likes would give him some changes in his schedule that would most likely get him thinking about other things. If he has time to be on the computer everyday after school, he has too much free time, even with his homework. Keeping him busy and telling him that he cannot send more than one email per day (or every other day) is probably your best bet.
Good luck, and all my best from another mom with a boy!
D.
2 moms found this helpful
L.P. answers from Memphis on October 24, 2008
AMEN Becky!!! I totally agree with her on absolutely everything!!
Most important and most immediate thing right now...DON"T PUT COMPUTERS IN BEDROOMS...PUT IT NEXT TO THE T.V. IN THE MAIN FAMILY ROOM!!!!! Otherwise you have just tossed your sweet child and his innocence to the lions!
Let me recommend Dr. James Dobson's book "Bringing Up Boys". It's for conservative Christian parents who want to make Godly and successful young men out of their little boys!
And let this set up your "guard mode" for when your daughter hits this age in a few years. It won't be right to be more strict on her than your son. So be firm with him and she'll know what to expect! And when she asks for a cell phone, or even to just call a boy, remember what you thought of your son's little "girlfriend"! Don't ever let your DD's reputation be harmed by the things you give in to at home.
Proud of you for seeking advice!! Shows you want what's BEST for your kids...not what's COOL for your kids!
2 moms found this helpful
S.U. answers from Raleigh on October 25, 2008
Hi K., well firstly, he's going to feel these feelings whether he's got e-mail or not. I do remember having little boyfriends throughout elementary school, and puppy love is still a form of love and is pretty strong, even for a 5th grader. I have to STRONGLY support, no computers in any kid's room ever until they move out of the house, literally. Needs to be in a high volume location, kitchen, playroom, etc. They never ever should have privacy on a computer (but I think it's a little much to sit over him). He needs to feel constant supervision, but it breeds ill feelings to feel suffocated. I also have to say I'm not sure if he needs an e-mail address at his age. What purpose does he have to have his own personal e-mail address? Why feel as if you have to go behind him? I'm thinking 8th grade maybe for my girls, but that's up for debate. I have limited my kids to a handful of websites that they like. If they need internet resources for school, I am on there. I do need to install the more strict parental controls on the computer, but in 5th grade, he should not have freedom on a computer, it should all be specifically outlined by you. As for a movie, I remember being dropped off for group outings at movies when I was in 5th grade, where a 'boyfriend' might be part of the group, but one on one? No way... maybe when he's 15! LOL Good luck with whatever you decide, this is all hard for us 'growing' parents!
2 moms found this helpful
M. answers from Memphis on October 24, 2008
well first i want to say that you have to be careful these days..would def monitor the email address..and most importantly have a talk with you son..but try to be open minded and discussion type..not all lecturey...
on the other hand i wanted to say that 5th grade was my first true "boyfriend"......it just depends on the maturity of kids these days..I think kids are overly charged with all the sexual and adult content exposed to..but we can not lock our kids in a bubble..that will just makes matters worse..but have to educate
2 moms found this helpful
D.P. answers from Raleigh on October 24, 2008
K.,
I think this is probably just puppy love and I wouldn't take it too seriously just yet. You're his mother and it is probably embarrassing for him to discuss these things with you now that he is moving more towards puberty. My advice is to perhaps let dad or another family male, like an uncle or older cousin, do the talking. It is a little different when it comes from another male and he may feel a little less embarrassed if it comes from them. Also, I would recommend getting a good internet blocking software which just allows him to access just approved sites, and to have a "family" email account that he has to use for email correspondence. I absolutely agree that it's time for the birds and the bees , but you might be surprised at what he already knows (my teaching experience taught me to never underestimate a child's knowledge...lol). Go to the library and browse in the 649 call number section of the shelves. All of the books pertaining to the birds and the bees subject will be in this area. Good luck!
2 moms found this helpful
E.M. answers from Louisville on October 25, 2008
hes 11! of course hes not going to want you to see what hes doing. he doesnt want mommy looking over him all the time. hate to say it but most kids by 11 know about the birds and bees my husbands brother (15) was already having sex at that age. that may scare you but it happens.. you say you trust him so go with that... trust him then if he gives you a reason not to deal with it then
1 mom found this helpful
Email