K.M. asks from Santa Ana, CA on September 01, 2008
2 1/2 Yo Throwing Things
My daughter has always been very active and independent from day one. She wants to do everything herself. And usually as long as it's not going to be dangerous, I let her at least try. She frequently will ask for help if she realizes that she needs it. But she has been getting more and more defiant about things over the last month or so. And for the last 2 weeks, she has started throwing things when she gets mad, or frustrated, or just feels like it. I usually can handle it with aplomb, but now she has started throwing food. Including throwing an entire cup of milk into the ailse of the restaurant we were trying to eat at. And the only reason I think she did it is that she didn't want to drink it. I was mortified. Fortunately, it didn't splash on any other customers. This throwing food thing is really new. I just tell her to say "no thank you" if she doesn't want something and 90% of the time that's what she does. But I just can't deal with her pitching food and dishes across the room. I've given her time outs and she gets very apologetic and cries. But then she does it again. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated. And if this is just normal 2 1/2 yo stuff, then I'd be happy just to know that I'm not alone and that "this too shall pass", as the saying goes.
2 moms found this helpful
Featured Answers
J.A. answers from Los Angeles on September 03, 2008
My Daughter use to throw too. what i did was get a box or clothes basket put it where she could see it but couldnt get to it. and when ever she threw a toy or miss used a toy she imediatly had to put the TOY in the time out box. where it stayed for the rest of the day. the next day we stated the day emptying all of the toys out of the time out box. her toy throwing days didnt last much longer. :)
FOOD, since she is an independent girl (like my daughter) tell her that if she cant be a big girl and handle feeding herself or using the big girl cup them mommy will have to feed her and give her a sippy cup. good luck!
2 moms found this helpful
More Answers
J.A. answers from Los Angeles on September 03, 2008
My Daughter use to throw too. what i did was get a box or clothes basket put it where she could see it but couldnt get to it. and when ever she threw a toy or miss used a toy she imediatly had to put the TOY in the time out box. where it stayed for the rest of the day. the next day we stated the day emptying all of the toys out of the time out box. her toy throwing days didnt last much longer. :)
FOOD, since she is an independent girl (like my daughter) tell her that if she cant be a big girl and handle feeding herself or using the big girl cup them mommy will have to feed her and give her a sippy cup. good luck!
2 moms found this helpful
R.L. answers from Reno on September 02, 2008
I would have to say it sounds to me like an age appropriate (haha) reaction. My son did the same types of things and I was told it was due mostly to frustration at that age to not being able to have the control they want and to be able to fully communicate what they are feeling yet. It sounds like you are doing your best to stem the reactions and teach her more appropriate ways to respond. Keep up the good work, and yes, it will pass...eventually:)
T.D. answers from Los Angeles on September 02, 2008
Yes, part of it is the age and the inability to handle frustration. But that doesn't mean that you should let even one throwing session go unaddressed. A hard and fast rule in our house has always been, "You throw it, you lose it." No exceptions. Try it and I'll bet within one week the throwing will decrease greatly if not stop altogether.
Good luck!!
A.B. answers from Las Vegas on September 02, 2008
My son started throwing things when he was about 3 years old and it lasted about a year. I found that he did it when he was trying to communicate something he was wanting and I either didn't hear him or couldn't understand him, so he would get frustrated and throw something. I started paying close attention to him when he was eating and when I could tell he was getting irritated I would tell him to ask me for help. That solved everything!
A.S. answers from Los Angeles on September 02, 2008
My daughter went through a small issue with this but we stopped it early. She had to pick it up. She was not happy and she had to stay their until she picked it up and put it down nicely and apologized. Be firm, consistent, and remain calm with her knowing you will not relent.
Good luck
H.R. answers from San Diego on September 02, 2008
Well K. they don't call it terrible two's for nothing.... Yes she is looking for independence however this should not come from being defiant.
Hold her cup when she wants a drink. don't give it to her. Take that power away until she appreciates it.
Keep her snack and food (meals) where she can see it but it's out of reach so she has to ask for it.
" Your lunch is here when your hungry..there will not be another lunch..AND stick to it.. if she throws it don't keep replacing it and bringing it back to her and or refilling her cup.
Slow down Mom...and don't worry. You will prob only have to put her meals up a few day's she'll get the picture. Keep your words minimul to her and be matter of fact.
If she has to miss a meal it wont hurt her.
She is very smart and she's working you for attention.
Tootles
M.B. answers from Los Angeles on September 01, 2008
This may be normal but not exceptable behavior. I would very sternly tell her know and make her help clean up the mess. Also, if she throws her food then she is done she doesn't get any more until next meal. You have to show her she doesn't get anything by acting out. There was a time I was unable to take my daughter out to restaurants because she wouldn't listen. This to will pass but for now stay strong and don't give in to her bad behavior.
M.Z. answers from Reno on September 02, 2008
It is a phase. My son is at the same place. They are testing their boundaries. It is really hard, but try and stand your ground. It really will pass. At least it did with my older 2! Good luck!
Email