L.J. asks from Valdosta, GA on July 06, 2010
14-Year-old Daughter's Friend's "Lifestyles" Are Breaking Us! (Long, Sorry!)
I have 3 children, including 1 getting ready to go off to college. My 14-year old's best friend since 4th grade is an only child with a 3 income family (child support, mom & stepdad) & wealthy grandparents on both sides. Their other best friend has an almost identical family situation, minus the child support. We are not by any means poor and our children are well taken care of, but not spoiled rotten.
These other girls like to lounge at the pool ($5/day), visit the tanning bed 3x a week at $6 a pop, get mani's/pedi's every few weeks ($$$), go shopping "just because", eat out almost every day etc. When they come to my house to spend the nite, I always make a nice homemade dinner, dessert & buy them snacks, rent them movies, etc...which I have no problem with. But my house is "boring" & I don't take them to "do" anything (& we don't have a built-in pool, movie theatre, or hot tub), so my daughter always wants to go to the other girl's houses. Their mom's don't cook, so I have to send $20 for dinner, $10 for the movie theatre they will no doubt visit & $5 for the pool the next day, work out at the drop in gym ($7 a visit)...well, you get the idea. To be fair, the other girls mostly treat her when they go out to dinner since they don't cook--at ALL--but then I feel guilty because I can't reciprocate.
I just don't have that kind of money in my budget and I have 2 other kids! Believe me, she is not deprived...but I feel like such a tightwad when she asks me for all this in front of her friends! She has chores and gets $20 a week allowance, but thinks that she should get to "save" that for special clothing items, things she wants to buy that we won't get her & her "car fund" (she has a "goal" poster of saving $400 by her b-day in October so she can go on a big shopping spree). She gets invited to a lot of birthday parties as well where I have to send her with a $25 gift and they usually take the birthday person out to dinner, so I have to pay for my daughter's dinner & chip in for the guest of honor. UGH...it's just never ending!
I can't tell her she can't see her friends...any suggestions on how to handle this?? HELP!
MORE INFO:
Thanks for all the advice.
I say "No" WAY more often than I say "Yes" (she has been allowed to go to the tanning bed twice, manicure once). We are teaching her the value of a dollar by making her work hard for the $20. She buys a lot of her own clothes using allowance, gift money, etc. I explain all the time that we can't afford all those things. The problem goes like this: "Mom, can I spend the nite at _____'s house". I say "okay". Then when I'm dropping her off, she'll say (or the mom will say) "We're going to La Tortilla/Tacoville" tonite & ____ wants to go to the pool/tanning/gym tomorrow so I need money...or I get a call the next morning with "can you bring me some money because ______'s mom is taking us to a movie or xxxxx". 90% of the time, they don't allow her to pay for the eating out, but I still feel bad because I never take their daughter's out to eat & I always have to send the money just in case. It's embarrassing & difficult to always have to say "no" to my daughter in order for them to spend time together because THEY can never say "no" to theirs!
MomofTeens in Georgia
KansasMom: Your response was a little harsh.
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
S.K. answers from Kansas City on July 06, 2010
This question just makes me tired. We've gotten 3 girls through the teen years and they never had this stuff. We often heard about what their friends had. We just couldn't do it. It's not a contest. It's life and better to learn now that it's expensive. In a year she can work at McDonald's. In the meantime she needs to take a class for babysitting and start earning some money of her own. I think you are being generous with a 20 dollar allowance.
6 moms found this helpful
A.S. answers from Portland on July 06, 2010
My sister was very much like this growing up. She never understood money and kept asking my parents for more and more. She is now in her 40's, 3 kids, and just lots her house, and filled bankruptcy.
You should teacher her the value of money. You can't keep spending you don't have, and living the life style you can't avoid.
4 moms found this helpful
S.J. answers from Atlanta on July 06, 2010
her allowance should cover all of this extra stuff. I am not saying you should give her enough allowance to cover all of it, what I am saying is that she needs to learn how to prioritize what is important to her financially and if she is not getting enough allowance to cover everything she wants to spend money on, then she needs to find ways to earn extra money on her own. teach her about needs, wants & desires and how to save money for things that are important to her. she needs to learn now, not later. my mom never gave me money for spending time with friends, if we knew we were going to do something, it meant knowing in advance and planning for it. I think she will eventually learn that these friends are probably not real friends if she can't keep up with everything they do since it all sounds so superficial.
4 moms found this helpful
More Answers
R.S. answers from San Antonio on July 06, 2010
Let's see $20 a week...save $5 for car/future shopping spree/friend's birthday party...one day a week at the pool, $5...one visit to the tanning bed OR the gym a week, $7... and $3 for the dollar menu at the local fast food place. Learning to manage her money and tell her friends "no, can't do it", priceless!!
Oh, and if I EVER put my mom on the spot by asking for something in front of friends or other people. I was grounded, because it is just plane RUDE to manipulate in that manner. Although, you could just tell her, "well you have your allowance...have fun!" and let her go. HUGS!!
8 moms found this helpful
R.M. answers from Topeka on July 06, 2010
Whoa!!!! I truly cannot believe this!!! I think it is time for a reality check for your daughter!! It is not her fault that she wants to do all of these things, it is your fault for allowing it to happen. You need to sit her down and have a discussion with her about what you can and cannot afford. What is going to happen when the other two children suddenly have rich friends that you need to finance their activities with? Will you be going out to look for another job or will your husband??? It is time to draw the line and be firm about it. I cannot imagine that those parents are expecting your child to pay for her own dinner when they go out to eat...unless it is just the girls going out and if so what on EARTH are 14 year old girls doing at expensive restaurants by themselves???
I think it is time for a reality check for everyone involved.
7 moms found this helpful
L.A. answers from Austin on July 06, 2010
Great advice,. One thing I will add. My daughter and her friends were never allowed to ask for permission to go to a friends home, ask for money or argue with the answers we parents gave our children in front of anyone.
It had to be a private conversation. This way when we said no, or we needed to ask/share extra information or private family information, this was not discussed in front of others.
Let your daughter know each time she does this, your answer will be no.
We started this way back when the kids were in elementary school and it worked great. Our children learned to excuse themselves when other parents and children spoke about these private subjects.
They also learned that we would not hold back if pushed us once we had given our answer in front of others and we would not be embarrassed, but that they may end up embarrassed in front of their friends by our response. .
7 moms found this helpful
P.M. answers from Portland on July 06, 2010
I agree with the other moms. Not only are you within your rights to determine how much you find reasonable to pay for your daughter's extras, you are doing her a disservice to keep paying when cornered into it. Her expectations are probably becoming pretty unrealistic, and when the truth finally hits her, it's gonna be a shock. Probably when she's out on her own for the first time.
In the meantime, I would let the more well-off families pay, if they're willing. I'll bet what you find to be a burden is no big deal to them.
Show your daughter your family finances – income and the expenses – and tell her exactly how much extra you are willing to budget on supporting her friendships. Once she sees herself tallied against other needs and expenses, she might realize she's expecting too much from you.
Then stick with your budget. If she wheedles, whines, begs, storms, or in any way demands more, just tell her that you understand her wishes, you sympathize, and it's not going to happen. If she ramps up the pressure, or asks you in front of her friends, warn her that she'll lose 5% (or more) of her budget for the next month. Then stick to your decision. Give her a chance to start budgeting and deferring her own desires before she can spend herself into debt. She won't suddenly learn those skills without practice.
There's also a book that will give you some wonderful techniques for being clear about your own expectations and need for her cooperation. It gives examples for just about any parenting situation you'll find yourself facing: How to Talk So Kids Will Listen, and Listen So Kids Will Talk.
6 moms found this helpful
S.K. answers from Kansas City on July 06, 2010
This question just makes me tired. We've gotten 3 girls through the teen years and they never had this stuff. We often heard about what their friends had. We just couldn't do it. It's not a contest. It's life and better to learn now that it's expensive. In a year she can work at McDonald's. In the meantime she needs to take a class for babysitting and start earning some money of her own. I think you are being generous with a 20 dollar allowance.
6 moms found this helpful
M.H. answers from Raleigh on July 06, 2010
Ahh I feel for you (and your daughter)! I grew up in a town where most of the kids had more money than I did too. My parents were definitely not poor by most standards, but many of my friends thought nothing of buying a $400 dress for their boyfriend's prom or why they were driving a year old Saab to school everyday. One of my friend's moms even footed a homecoming dance dinner bill as a "business expense" (there were almost 20 of us and the bill was over $1000). The way my parents and I got through it was this. If I went out with another girl's family, I would offer to cover my meal, but I had to have that money to pay for it(my parents never gave me any). I was never asked to pay (since the girl's family was the one going out). Manis/pedis were for special occasions and if I wanted them for something more than prom/homecoming, I paid the bill. Does the pool they go to have a summer membership? It probably would be cheaper to do that in the future rather than pay $5 a pop, and the movies...that was always me!
I started babysitting for neighbors and family friends when I was 12 so I could begin to earn the extra money I wanted and needed. I would tell your daughter that your family is unable to keep up with her extravagant lifestyle and that she will be paying for all unnecessary items in the future (dinners out, gym time, tanning, mani/pedis, movie theater, etc.). She's not going to be happy, but at least you will know that you are teaching her to be appreciative of what she has. (I still have a friend who doesn't understand that a movie is a treat, not something that you do multiple times throughout the week!)
6 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from Honolulu on July 06, 2010
I read your edit: Perhaps, instead of your daughter telling you these things at the LAST minute, tell her she needs to tell you AHEAD Of time.
Next, she has a lot of outings/money being spent.... it should not be anything more than what you do... ie: do YOU go out and have lunch and mani's and pedi's and movies and spas/gym/tanning/pool time/movies, and dinners out and all that stuff JUST like her???? A 14 year old? Do you and your Hubby do that to that extent?
Again, she is a teenager. Not an adult. And she does more and spends more and has more luxuries... than even I have, and my Hubby combined!
Just a thought... comparatively.
Keep things in proportion... and..... R.a.t.i.o.n.a.l.
----------------------------------
I like Suzi's answer below.
Geez., what a conundrum.
But really, it is a choice.
Keeping up with the J.' is not the way.
Teach your girl... how to be self-sufficient, how to value money and time, about values and "choices", about friends, about earning money, about spending money, about budgeting etc.
Kids younger than 14, learn these things in school to and from their parents.
My kids are only 3 and 7... and we teach them that already.
And what the heck with visiting tanning beds... at FOURTEEN years old! Geez, that is really indulged in kids, if you ask me.
And mani's and pedi's???? What the heck? What is wrong with that picture??? They are 14 year olds!
Next, THINK... is that the kind of girl you want your girl to become???? To be high-maintenance and live off of guys, later???? Or to be coming to you at 21 years old still asking for money and indulgences????
I hope NOT.
Teach her to be her OWN PERSON... and to LOVE what she earns... and to respect her hard work for things and objects.
Don't teach her to be a follower... of this.
Teach her to be PROUD of HER HOME... and that you/she does NOT have to "entertain" these girls like everyday is a spa day. Who are these girls? The Kardashians?
I personally, would NOT want, my daughter to grow up that way... nor with those values either or thinking "spending" and "shopping sprees" are what life is.
I would.. have your girl, join a charitable cause.... to help other kids or adults. To donate her money and time that way. Make it a requirement.
Mostly, don't feel embarrassed about it... because YOU are being a role model for your girl. If you are self-conscious about it... she will be too.
Teach her OTHER values, and be PROUD of your and your Hubby's parenting. NOT teaching her about 'comparing' and how to be like others.
Teach her to be her own person, and how to KNOW.... the differences in how time and money is spent.... and how to be proud of her own family's abilities....
Your daughter is old enough... to have a talk about that. Sit down with her and just talk about it. It is not about have's and have not's.
We have a friend that is VERY wealthy, that my daughter is friends with her daughter. I am the Mom's friend as well. I tell her honestly that we cannot spend money on certain things or that it is outside our budget. I don't hide it. I say this in front of my daughter too. She understands and values, the "family" budget... she respects that. It is a life lesson.
This friend as well, is also very mature and is not "shallow" nor materialistic... she respects the differing economic abilities of ALL people. Not just her socio-economic level.
And quite frankly, I don't care if she thinks I am a tight-wad. But I know... she respects my money concerns... she is a Mom too. And I am a SAHM. There is no problem about it, about money levels.
all the best,
Susan
6 moms found this helpful
T.F. answers from Dallas on July 06, 2010
We have a 15 yr old only daughter. I will give you a perspective from our view. We are not super wealthy but we hold our own well and have no debt. Our daughter is not spoiled rotten but there is nothing she really "wants". When someone says she is spoiled she replies "I am well cared for". She buys a lot of her clothes with her weekly money $50 and that covers her for any social activity as well.
As a family and having an only child, we always include at least 1 friend when we go on vacation, dinners, movies, etc. She likes to go to the country club and I take small groups of girls there. We DO NOT expect recriprocation.... when the girls have a good time,and I hear a genuine thank you.... that is all that matters. I have no issue with kids hanging out here. When we take someone on vacation with us, we pay for everything except the keepsakes the guest buys to take home.
One note to you........I am a lover of home cooked meals and I enjoy cooking. I do cook like you do. There are 2 friends who love to eat dinner here, it is the only home made food they get. I overheard 1 friend say...."I love to have dinner at your house, the food is so great". That meant a lot to me. So you, are probably making a positive effect on some girls and don't realize it.
Also, when our daughter joins another family, I make sure she is covered financially as to not be any financial burden on another family.
It is never ending. For the bdays, we usually do a $25 gift card. I don't know if you have a Sephora but a general gift card there is inside a really neat makeup mirror. A $10 gift card is really dressed up from Sephora. I know it is tough, try to hang in there. Sounds like you have a good level headed daughter.
As for the tanning bed? NO WAY....my daughter is NOT allowed in a tanning bed, no matter how reasonable it is. Manis/Pedis? yes she does this about once every 3-4 months.
Good luck!
5 moms found this helpful
Email