C.F. asks from Pittsburgh, PA on November 24, 2009
14 (Almost 15)-Month Old - Gaining Too Much?
My daughter was born at 6 lbs. 8 oz. I breastfed exclusively for about 6 months, and she gained weight quickly, always hitting right around the 50% in weight. At her last dr. visit (for an ear infection) last week, she was up just over 23 lbs. at 31 1/2 inches long, and my husband and I have both noticed that her belly is a little rounder and her cheeks are a little chubbier than we've seen before. She is with her grandma during the work day, but this is my general understanding of her eating habits:
Morning: 1/2 c. oatmeal made with whole milk with 1/2 of an apple chopped up (ususally doesn't eat it all),
Afternoon: Mostly, A scrambled egg or a yogurt and some bread. Yesterday it was some chicken noodle soup. She probably also has either a peeled apple and/or some halved grapes.
Home with Mommy: She snacks on about 1/2 c.of dry cheerios and some water.
Dinner: Changes, but last night it was 1 egg + 1 egg white scrambled with a sprinkling of cheese, 1/4 cup of corn nibblets, and 1 unbuttered breadstick. Plus a couple of black olives from my salad.
Before sleep: About 6 oz. of warm whole milk.
Are we doing anything wrong? Should I double-check with my MIL that she is eating just what I think she's eating? Or are we just over-reacting (I recovered from an eating disorder about 14 years ago). She is a very active girl and spends her time running around any room that she's in!
So What Happened?™
There is such irony in parenting. The very things we guard against in our children are often the ones that create the very problem we're trying to avoid. I was chubby growing up, and the teasing is what led me to develop eating problems as a teen-ager. But, as some helpful moms have pointed out, obsessing over what my daughter eats could lead her down a similar path. This was a big lesson for me. Thank you.
As for my daughter's health, I found out it was not so much what my MIL was feeding her,but what my husband's grandmother (who helps my MIL take care of the baby 3X a week) was feeding her. Apparently, when GMIL (I suppose) was doing the care-taking, my daughter was snacking on pumpkin pie and all kinds of cookies and crackers. I didn't put it together until I realized that my daughter was coming down with a diaper rash and was spitting up frequently on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. So, I asked, "So, Gram (GMIL), do you like helping mom with the baby?" Then it was, "Oh, yes! I let her have just a wee bit of pie...and cookies...and these chocolate cereal bars, well, it says that they have less saturated fat than regular candy bars, so they're healthy..." AHA!
I just told her that the baby really likes fruit and veggies and whole grain cereal. They're her FAVORITE FOODS to snack on. And wonderful GMIL said, "Oh, OK. Then I'll make sure she gets those to snack on."
So, maybe problem solved. I will pull back on worrying about the weight and I think that I now have a new partner in keeping my wonderful daughter healthy!
Featured Answers
L.G. answers from Philadelphia on November 30, 2009
My daughter went through chubbier stages and then would thin out. You can tell by looking at her monthly photos the changes in her weight. I wouldn't worry about it if the doctor isn't worried. If they thought there was a problem with her weight, they would have said so at the appointment. Just keep offering healthy choices.
C.W. answers from State College on November 29, 2009
My first was 8 12 at birth and gained 2lbs within two weeks, exclusively bf and had a cleft lip even. He was in the 99th percentile every time we went to the doctor's. He looked very chubby through his toddler years. But he ate well and was active. He is now 6 1/2 & is a skinny but tall kid. I think the key is just to keep them eating well and active and don't stress about their body image and they will grow to be a healthy happy kid.
More Answers
D.P. answers from Pittsburgh on November 24, 2009
She is fine. Does she need to be persuaded to eat the food you listed? Does she want MORE than that? Kids are amazing judges of how much they need to eat. Focus on teaching her to eat when she's hungry and to stop when she's full. Don't fall into the clean-plate trap and things like that. Those are all BAD behavior habits that are learned, as I'm sure you are well aware. I hope she's getting more milk than just the 6 oz. you listed at night. She should still be having milk with at least 2 of 3 meals and her nighttime snack. I doubt you can overfeed a baby of this age. They won't eat if they are not hungry. Just continue to freely offer healthy foods. She'll let you know everything you need to!
Kids fill out and then sprout up over and over. You'll see this many times!
1 mom found this helpful
N.K. answers from Philadelphia on November 25, 2009
It sounds like she eats fine to me and her weight is exactly average. My daughter is about the same age, height and weight and eats about the same, although mine drinks much more milk (probably you just didn't write about her drinks). I would suggest, warmly and kindly, that you find someone in your life that you can speak to about your continuing recovery from the eating disorder. I think your daughter sounds perfectly healthy and she needs you to be, too, and that includes keeping an eye on your anxiety over her food choices. You can do it. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
K.B. answers from Harrisburg on November 24, 2009
You want to keep kids active no matter what their weight is as it's just the healthy thing to do. Take her to the mall and let her run or to the kiddie area there.
With that said, kids go up and down in their weight, some more noticeable than others. When they're inbetween growth spurts they will fill out more. Then suddenly they'll grow and thin out as their height goes up. Then the cycle starts again with rounding out as they're not growing in height, then shoot in height again.
Looks like she's eating healthy so no problem. Just make sure that she's getting 18-24 ounces of milk a day and use juice split with water only when she finishes her milk during the day. Juice is just a treat as real fruit is more nutritious.
Toddlers fluctuate a lot so I wouldn't stress. Just feed her healthy foods and let her get exercise and run and climb when possible and she'll be fine!
All 5 of my kids were and are so different in shape. With my triplets, they all eat the same things but are completely differently shaped and different looking. One has a low metabolism, is much taller and built like a football player but lumbering. Another is small, thin, and athletic. The other is thin and long torso. One has short and wide feet, another long and average, another long and narrow. So kids just vary so don't stress about the little things.
K. B
mom to 5 including triplets
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HarrisburgPAChat
events and chat within 2 hour radius
1 mom found this helpful
T.H. answers from Pittsburgh on November 24, 2009
Your daughter is fine. She's probably just going to go through a growth spurt soon. Babies this age know how much they need to eat, and their weight and height can bounce up in the blink of an eye because of sporadic growth periods. As long as she's not filling up on fast food or fried fare (which it sounds like she's not), then there's no need to worry. Keep doing what your doing, all that you mentioned feeding her is healthy and appropriate for a baby this age. My son weighed more than that at her age ( he was always a chubby baby). By the time he tuned two he had gotten much taller and has been a relatively slender toddler ever since. I wouldn't try to cut back on her fat and calories because that can cause serious problems for someone so young who's still growing and developing so much.
1 mom found this helpful
C.S. answers from Harrisburg on November 24, 2009
oh my goodness I wouldn't worry too much mama! My 6 month old is 21 pounds ... yes I know, seems like a lot... but great uncle is 7 feet tall. Doc says it's normal and part of genetics. Besides, he's only 6 months so he'll grow out of this stage. I would just make sure your MIL is giving her healthy foods but otherwise it's pretty normal so I wouldn't worry. When she's 3 and going through the stage of being a picky eater you'll be glad she gained some weight beforehand. :)
1 mom found this helpful
E.F. answers from Pittsburgh on November 25, 2009
I agree with everyone else. She's fine. Unless she's being fed soda or juice all day, she's not going to overeat. My little buddy has a big "milk belly" hanging over his pants right now which is a sure sign that those same pants are about ready to be an inch too short. Out, then up. That's just the way they go.
This is a little hard to say in a message, but if you are having concerns about either your or her body image/size, you might want a little booster with a counselor or whomever you worked to recover from your eating disorder. All moms wonder if their kids are gaining too much/not enough weight, just make sure that your previous experiences aren't also part of that anxiety. As I understand it, eating disorders are often control disorders, and I'm wondering (playing armchair psychoanlyst here, which I am most assuredly NOT qualified to do) if you are having a little bit of a control issue about what she's eating when she's not with you? I may be WAY off base here, but just something to think about.
Good luck. And happy shopping for some new, taller baby clothes sometime soon! :-)
L.L. answers from Pittsburgh on November 26, 2009
C.,
My son just turned 14 mos & he was 6-9 at birth & now is 28.5 lbs & 31 inches tall. He has a round little belly & very chubby cheeks too. I think she sounds just fine. I imagine she will go up & down a bit in the weight percentile but much better to have a baby that's a little chubby than one that is too thin. As long as she's eating when she's hungry & being given healthy food (sounds like that is true) then I would not worry about her weight.
A.J. answers from Williamsport on November 25, 2009
I mean this in all sincerity and love, I was super alarmed by this message pertaining to a 15 month old-but now I see where you're coming from. At first I couldn't believe the carefully measured and unbuttered descriptions of daily food (I don't butter my kids whole grain bread either, but I'm just saying, it seemed notable in context with the half cups and half apples, and dr's perfect 50% weight chart), then when I saw you mention an eating disorder it sort of clicked.
Do not worry about rationing your child's food and don't watch her shape with a magnifying glass. She needs as much healthy food as she will eat. For her brain development and sleep habits. All my kids grew in spurts of "out" and then "up" Chubby one day, longer the next all through toddlerhood. They've always been somewhere totally average on the charts.
They eat no junk food at all, drink only watered down natural juice or organic milk, but they are allowed to eat as much as they want. They have to eat what I feed them for meals, and all the healthy snacks they want. They get a bite or two of cake at birthday parties and a sliver of Halloween chocolate (maybe 1/8 of a mini snickers) with their fruit for dessert for a couple of days after Halloween so junk doesn't become the forbidden fruit. They know what's only for rare occasions like ice cream because of sugar. The more healthy food they get used to liking the better before they get out in the junk food world. They have tons of energy for playing and sleep like stones.
I have no idea of their exact portions from day to day. But kids need natural essential fats for their brains-(olive oil, avocados, almond butter,)and most of all they need to learn not to be too obsessed with food.
Your daughter is so young, you really don't need to worry about a chubby round baby shape.
If you think your MIL may be secretly feeding her excessively fattening snacks with bad oils and sugars and and chemicals and fat in them like Jif or something, you could make sure she isn't. Read the labels on MIL's food and make sure nothing is artificial or sugary. Just worry about quality of food, not quantity. Great job caring about your daughter's health! Keep it up, but don't worry about her eating too much at this age!
Email